HN

Need help?
<- Back
Google Opal

Google Opal

gmays

Comments (106)

  • kamranjon
    Does it seem, I'm not sure, ironic maybe? That the main example here is "An app that writes blog posts" - "Researches a topic and writes a blog post about it" - that the company who helped champion the network effects of the internet and surface truly useful search results is now helping to destroy that very same thing they built their entire business on?
  • croemer
    "Opal is not available in your country yet"Thanks for having me click through 5 screens including giving access to Google Drive to tell me that in the end.
  • agentifysh
    I think Google is going to do with consumer AI as they have done with search engine. Full monopolization. They own the lumberyard and the forest.They'll just see whats popular and then clone, launch and instantly own verticals.It's over for the little SaaS guys.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BxFQYw_MmAA
  • schappim
    Discussion when launched 5 months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44681786
  • pvtmert
    2 cents from me1. "it's not available in your country yet" -- although I am currently in (and connected to) Czech republic train, my account is based on Luxembourg. Not sure which one takes precedence, but sad to see...2. Join Discord -- Unexpected to see this from a Google product. More interestingly, do they really have people/staff there? Or is it just bunch of AI Agents running the discord server, not sure. (Haven't joined either)
  • JumpCrisscross
    The unresponsive search bar centred on the viewport is all I need to know about this product.Google may deliver us the AI future Altman promised. The PM who thinks animated PNGs pass for anything real is not on that path.
  • jdthedisciple
    Maybe it's just me, but it doesn't inspire anything in me.This idea of make-things-quick-without-any-real-skills seems fundamentally contrary to achieving lasting quality...
  • sbalough
    Anyone have comments actually about Opal? Curious if anyone tried it.
  • tessierashpool9
    "An app that writes blog posts" ... how about an app that reads blog posts? ^^
  • apexalpha
    “Join our Discord…”That is a bit unexpected to see. Start Up vibes, haha.Looks like another insane leap forward this.
  • LeoPanthera
    I didn't get far with this because it wants access to my entire Google Drive, which I declined. Credit to Google for even offering the chance to say "no", I suppose.Why does it need that?
  • pjmlp
    Opal is Optimizely AI name, but I guess Google's being Google, they are the ones that need to now change the product name.https://www.optimizely.com/ai/
  • kinlan
    Here's the OSS repo for Google Opal: https://github.com/breadboard-ai/breadboard
  • mcintyre1994
    Do any of the example apps work for anyone? I tap “try now” on one, and it just opens a page with its logo/name/description. There’s a sidebar menu that just has its name, and a restart app button that does nothing. I can’t see how to make the app do anything.
  • anon
    undefined
  • qweiopqweiop
    I wonder how android developers feel about this. You put years of your life into supporting a companies product, and then they actively try and remove the need for your job to exist.
  • mrtksn
    Funny, everyone is trying to do the same thing. IMHO no one nailed it yet.
  • ulrischa
    Not available in Germany and I assume the rest of Europe
  • BaudouinVH
    "not available in your country" (I'm in Belgium)
  • ramon156
    > Not available in your country yetSee ya in 6 months !
  • stpedgwdgfhgdd
    That will make 300https://killedbygoogle.com/
  • binary132
    These companies won’t rest until they’ve figured out how to get rid of all their actual employees and have replaced their business strategy with “just click YES on whatever the slop machine cranks out this quarter”
  • zja
    > Join our Discord for support and sharing feedbackI’m surprised to see Google directing people to Discord, do they do that for other products?
  • colesantiago
    What is this AI mini app?Do this make an actual production Flutter app or something?
  • ActionHank
    First thing I thought was “oh, neat, another google product they will kill”.
  • joking
    not available in your country...I suppose for any in europe waking up like me that I can save you one click and some time.
  • wojciii
    What is the usual life expectancy of a Google product?Google usually kills projects. What's the point in using this?
  • barrenko
    "The horror, the horror..."
  • nimchimpsky
    [dead]
  • giancarlostoro
    Problem I see with this being "codeless" is now Google owns everything. They can just hold your app hostage at any price point.
  • maxpert
    One more Google product destined to die!
  • thisisauserid
    Cute . I think we're all fine with anything that remotely threatens Vercel.