HN

Need help?
<- Back
In space, no one can hear you kernel panic (2020)

In space, no one can hear you kernel panic (2020)

p0u4a

Comments (16)

  • dfox
    > running identical software on multiple computer systems is the name of the software-architecture gameIn the railway signalling industry (which for historically obvious reasons is obsessed with reliability) there even is a pattern of running different software implementing the same specification, written by different team, running on a different RTOS and different CPU architecture.
  • somat
    "From the dawn of the Space Age through the present, NASA has relied on resilient software running on redundant hardware to make up for physical defects, wear and tear, sudden failures, or even the effects of cosmic rays on equipment."An interesting case study in this domain is to compare the Saturn V Launch Vehicle Digital Computer with the Apollo Guidance ComputerNow the LVDC, that was a real flight computer, triply redundant, every stage in the processing pipeline had to be vote confirmed, the works.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Launch_Vehicle_Digital_Compute...Compare the AGC, with no redundancy. a toy by comparison. But the AGC was much faster and lighter so they just shipped two of them(three if you count the one in the lunar module) and made sure it was really good at restarting fast.There is a lesson to be learned here but I am not sure what it is. Worse is better? Can not fail vs fail gracefully?
  • KurSix
    The contrast with modern software development is striking. Today we often rely on fast iteration and patching problems in production. Spacecraft software is the opposite
  • thomascountz
    OT: I really enjoyed The Increment when it was first being released. It felt like the first software engineering practitioner's publication and introduced me to a lot of new people to follow.
  • throwaradfy5745
    How would these considerations affect Musk's space cloud ?
  • anon
    undefined
  • anon
    undefined
  • gnabgib
    (2020)
  • adampunk
    Do not attempt to adjust your television. We control the horizontal. We control the vertical.We know Glenn is loquacious.
  • shadowbyte17
    interesting point about patching in production – it's a totally different mindset. we had a similar issue with a legacy system at my old job, felt like a constant firefighting situation.