<- Back
Comments (153)
- malfistAn passive investors are going to get hosed by this thanks to NASDAQ cooking the rules to favor Elon and his band of misfits.No longer will there be a year of price discovery for index funds, 15 days. Meaning index funds have to buy it at the peak of the hype cycle. Will be a huge wealth transfer from mom and pop retirement accounts to the ultra wealthy.
- saadn92The xAI piece is the one that stands out to me. $258B for a lab that's burning $1.46B/quarter against $430M revenue, valued almost entirely on a merger anchor from four months ago.
- sharemywinNot bad for about $12-$16B in total actual revenue.net income probably: $1.5B – $3BP/E:500-1000Of course people will trip overthemselves to buy it up.
- protealIt’s also one of the thinnest floats IPO’ing. They’re only selling less than 5% of the company. That introduces a lot of sensitivity in the valuation, not to mention there exists a bit of game theory around fund managers needing to join in to maintain nominal returns with their peers.Check out Matt Levine commentary, which goes into more detail (SpaceX Indexing) https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/newsletters/2026-03-31/are...
- Octoth0rpeDoes it make sense to value Starship Commercial Launch at $170B, _and_ Falcon 9/Heavy at $100B? I would expect that if Starship achieves its operational goals, then it should quickly deprecate nearly all uses of Falcon, the exceptions being national security launches that require validating the launcher, or Dragon launches for similar reasons. Even those categories are likely on a countdown the moment starship is rapidly reusable.
- genidoi> Starship at $170B is pure option value on technology still in advanced testing.The argument that Starship is somehow an experimental/unproven technology that might fail to materialise was absurd but plausible sounding before flight 1, there were many new technologies simultaneously being deployed to a single launch system in one go.But after 3 tower catches of the booster demonstrating centimetres of guided precision of the entire stack, this is becoming a tired argument.I know the author is not making that case at all here, but it seems like one the core reasons to undervalue SpaceX is that Starship might not work out, and this all sounds exactly like how reusability might not work out for the Falcon 9 from 10 years ago.
- lokimedesI know it’s easy to sit at home being indignant at the internet, but how on earth does an ISP with 10M subscribers and the most expensive infrastructure in the solar system ever come out to be worth $300B? They even have to routinely replenish their “cell towers” as their orbits decay.Any mid-sized country would have multiple cellphone and Internet providers with larger customer bases and less upkeep.
- tliptayGrok: lots of competitors & my 4th choice in LLM models.Starship: zero competitors & potentially makes humans inter-planetary.Seems crazy if investors put more value on Grok.
- boringgAnyone in this thread know how much SpaceX investors got diluted when they bought xAI/GROK?
- jgbuddyWere people overpaying 30% for tesla in 2010?
- ChrisArchitectRelated:The SpaceX IPO: retail investor noteshttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47612775SpaceX files to go publichttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47604155
- bobtheborgHaving never really looked at valuations, my ignorant mind can get from Starlink's 10M subscribers to a $380B valuation. If you make $100/mo/user that's 12B/yr and that with a higher 50x P/E ratio is 60B. If you go to 100x, that's $120B.
- paxysEveryone is so confident in their reading of tea leaves
- rvzAll these IPOs are extremely bearish and mirroring the 2019 race-for-the-exit IPOs out there.Of course once again, you are "not allowed" to be early into pre-IPO companies which is where the actual money is made.The moment several companies start IPOing, you are already too late for those multiples and have to wait for a massive crash until these stocks reach all time lows after IPO.
- righthandWall Street, ICE jobs, bs AI valuations, etc is proof that there are just enough stupid people in this country to ruin it all for the rest of us.
- vesnanomikai[dead]