HN

Comments (88)

• Menu

  throw4847285
  This review is just a plot synopsis. There are no quotes from the book to give me a sense of the quality of the writing. The review feels targeted at somebody who is already bought into the premise, not somebody from the outside who wants to know if "There Is No Antimemetics Division" is a good book or not. In that sense, it totally fails as a book review.
• Menu

  cws
  This article says “Book Review:” but then doesn’t provide the title of a book. I’m confused.:)
• Menu

  mjburgess
  I dislike the ending, at least of v2. In it, the author basically gives a fleshed out (christian, neoplatonist) metaphysics to the world he's created which basically amounts to: heaven exists, humans win against the devil, etc. And the ending itself is a self-conscious version of an ascension narrative. It's a very 90deg turn ending to a book otherwise more interested in a world in which heaven is never accessible.
• Menu

  pnw
  I read whatever version of this book was available to download in 2020 and really enjoyed it. Some very original ideas. I didn't find the writing clunky, and I read way too much.
• grimgrin
  You can read the original here https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/antimemetics-division-hubThere is also the rough draft. I've only read the wiki and the first draft of bookOddly I gifted the actual book away before reading it (I can buy it again, I thought)
• Menu

  munificent
  I liked this one a lot. If you like weird fiction and enjoyed Jeff Vandermeer's Annhilation, there's a good chance you'll like this.If you don't like weird fiction, odds are you'll bounce off it.
• EliRivers
  The core conceit lent itself so well to a (subverted) introductory "As you know" chapter that I didn't even notice it until I'd read it. Bravo for that alone.That said, from the review: "open source maintainership as cosmic horror." Genuine laugh.
• Menu

  xnx
  24 days ago: Sci-Fi Short Film “There Is No Antimemetics Division” https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47363133
• Menu

  scrumbledober
  It's surely not a great book and if you are someone who reads a book every few months i wouldn't recommend it. It's very weird and different and fun, though. I suggest it for people who read a lot of sci-fi and are looking for something that doesn't feel the same as 10 other books they've already read.
• mjg2
  I just finished this book and complained about it the whole time. The prose is amateur and peppered with cliches (e.g. you should be fined for publishing the phrase "their suit was so sharp it could cut"). His attempt to write about the inner thoughts of the characters was pretty simple. The descriptions of violence and horror also felt child-like, especially the dialogue during those moments (e.g. Redd's introduction). The landscapes are bland, with lots of repetition. Personally, the redaction technique got boring fast when he would take up entire pages of the book to convey absent memories. He could use his words to convey this instead of black-boxes.I will give the author credit on how they deal with their characters' memories and the re-development of their thoughts, and the usage of time-jumping was reasonable (some books jump around too much, as if these time-skips improve a boring plot). Also the convention for how they solve their dilemma was enjoyable.Overall, I think the author relies too much on a vocal fandom around the SCP Foundation to glorify the book. I think there is potential for a saga of books but there needs to be more effort in the drafting and editing process to raise the quality of the books to the level the universe deserves.
• Menu

  AnotherGoodName
  I wonder if this is for the rewrite or the first version.I read the first version and thought the first half was good and that the second half felt clunky. To the point where i don’t recommend it to anyone (not a huge negative, there’s just better books out there).
• Menu

  HardwareLust
  Good timing, the Kindle version is $1.99 right now.
• gmuslera
  It was a great book, but this review of it have its own value.
• anon
  undefined
• Schmerika
  Nice review; covers all the best points of the book, and its place in the world, without too many spoilers.
• dinkleberg
  It’s a fun book. Definitely worth a read.
• yakattak
  Crazy timing. My copy of this is being delivered today from the local bookshop. Great review.
• jmgimeno
  Couldn't finish it. I suppose it was not for me.
• Menu

  gostsamo
  TBH, the ending of Ra was a big letdown for me and though I like the small stories, I have the feeling that the author has issue building larger arcs. Still curious about this one and might read it just for the premise.
• subjectsigma
  I listened to the Audible version and either I read a completely different book or the anti-memetic effects are real, because the main character in the article has a different name and the plot synopsis doesn’t seem to match up.My short review would be: the book is very one-note, it’s like a horror movie that keeps doing the same jumpscare over and over again. Despite this I managed to enjoy it.
• SendItUp
  Loved this book. Definitely a mind trip
• solsafe_dev
  [dead]
• solsafe_dev
  [dead]
• mynamemh
  [flagged]
• endgame
  [flagged]
• measurablefunc
  Written by AI.
• Menu

  aaroninsf
  I read this.It's got some provocative ideas, which Stephen foregrounds.It's got a great hook, and like most writing incubated under circumstances like this, it leans hard into polished sharp introduction into a well-considered world with a very specific flavor.It's also—no better way to put it—crappy as a novel.It's not because the author can't string sentences together.It's because that's not what makes a novel function as a novel.Epic opening and premise establishment: 10/10Nice "plot twist", predictable in its inevitability if not its specifics; conforms to genre: 7/10Narrative arc: 2/10Ability to sustain meaningful tension and interest while working through the de rigeur mechanics of filling hundreds of pages: 1/10I get that there is a new readership with different expectations and styles of reading. (Looking at you tiktok; looking at you Dungeon Crawler Carl; looking at most successful YA fiction especially that which gets SPICEY and is released in 8-book series with a new volume every 11 months)If you're silverback and relish long-form fiction as previously conceived: set expectations accordingly.
• frankfrank13
  I have not read this book. I've been avoiding it for a while for the dumbest possible reason, which is that I only associate this book with SWE's.
• jppope
  The book was good but I struggled to finish it. You as a reader are encouraged to read because the ideas are so good but then it becomes hard to endure through to whatever resolution was waiting. For those unfamiliar, it will feel something like Momento - you start to feel yourself changing as you work through it. Worth a go for anyone looking for something different.