HN

Comments (112)

• Menu

  dmurray
  It seems completely in the spirit of Gas Town.A respectable software provider should warn you about this kind of behaviour at install time, and give you the opportunity to opt out. Gas Town fulfilled all its obligations in this regard with these (and other) warnings in the original announcement:> WARNING DANGER CAUTION> GET THE F** OUT> YOU WILL DIE
• Menu

  SwellJoe
  Based on my understanding of Gas Town, Beads, and Yegge's philosophy on AI that he's expressed in a variety of media, everything about the whole stack is designed to burn tokens. If you're not burning tokens, real fast, 24/7, you're losing the race. The race to where, I have no idea. Apparently, that includes him burning your tokens, too.
• Menu

  moab
  Is anyone surprised? I'm reminded of how I felt during the NFT craze. LLMs are extremely powerful when used with deliberate care. Gas Town is the exact opposite of what is needed to actually do useful things in prod. I guess good on Steve for doing what he does so well, and getting so much hype around a vibe coded mess.
• supermdguy
  From the most recent comment, looks like this is a bug, triggered by the system inadvertently activating an internal release tool [0]. Still a pretty wild bug, but not as dramatic as the title suggests. Which is kind of unfortunate honestly, the chaos of every gas town instance automatically contributing to itself would be beautiful to see.- https://github.com/gastownhall/gastown/blob/main/internal/fo...
• Menu

  mmastrac
  In one of my previous comments (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47770124) I asked if Gas Town has shipped anything of value. I did not expect it to be an Ouroborous.(Edit, thanks MisterTea: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47770805)
• Menu

  ex-aws-dude
  We need to dispel this notion that top open source contributors need to know anything about the project or even make contributions to itThat is a very 2025 mindset
• Menu

  woeirua
  I think a disclosure and a way to limit the total cost would be appropriate. If agents are capable of making contributions back to GasTown independently then I think it makes sense that users of GasTown should have to contribute some tokens to maintaining and improving the library. This is actually the most sustainable approach to maintaining open-source software that we've seen so far, and might be a pattern for other libraries in the future.That said... someone could also have their agents rip out this code or disable the functionality, so I doubt this is a serious inconvenience.
• Menu

  gbnwl
  Why is anyone still using or even talking about Gas Town? Now that HN is largely onboard with agentic development and has at least tried it themselves who's still under the impression that it's useful?
• Jimmc414
  Open source or not, there’s a strong argument that using someone’s API key to make unauthorized requests is a violation of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. Using their GitHub credentials to submit PRs without consent is also unauthorized use of access credentials.The “thoughtless design vs. malice” framing by Anthropic is generous. Shipping formulas that target steveyegge/gastown issues is intentional. Someone wrote those formulas, pointed them at the maintainer’s repo, and included them in the default install. Someone thought it was acceptable I guess because it’s open source?
• Menu

  progbits
  These people give the slopmachine credentials for their own github account?I know I should not be surprised at this point, yet they keep reaching new lows.
• Menu

  sdfwg
  This gets legally interesting. Yegge does not know what is going on in the codebase, so he can blame the AI. But the AI maliciously increases token consumption.That is clearly the fault of the clankers that produced this crap, so their providers are responsible.
• _doctor_love
  Is it possible to start a labor union in Gas Town?
• daft_pink
  Sounds like a good way to support open source. Would you support open source by donating tokens to improve the product? I definitely would!
• quux
  With the exception of a couple of comments that add context like that this might be a dev feature that was unintentionally enabled in a released version of Gas Town, the majority of the rest of this discourse seems to be:"I've never used Gas Town, but I'm mad that there are people who like something I don't like."
• thorum
  Isn’t this a permissions issue? Your “opt out” is using a GitHub access token that doesn’t allow it to happen.
• raincole
  It turns out crypto-adjacency is a very good proxy to see whether a person is trust-worthy.
• thomascountz
  Perhaps someone's Gas Town Tamagotchi will find this issue and fix it?
• triceratops
  Ngl if true it's entirely in keeping with the Mad Max theme.
• Menu

  jjmarr
  Wow, an example of AI engaging in powerseeking behaviour in the wild.This is an AI system given power to improve itself with zero oversight. One of the many Gas Town instances took an ethically questionable decision to accelerate its future rate of improvement. Since nobody reads code it got merged.I don't understand how we can be willfully ignorant of a scenario happening right in front of our eyes.
• S-E-P
  I appreciate that it's an issue to try and improve the product you are using currently. As if those tokens were totally "stolen" and not for your benefit is laughable.This is like when someone torrents and is immediately agro'd the moment your bittorrent client gives some poor passerby a kb of data
• Sevii
  He found a way to charge people for open source
• 08627843789
  How would Yegge know?
• slopinthebag
  So this is just straight-up theft right? Like it's directly equivilant to shipping with a bitcoin miner. I wonder what the spend would have amounted to and if you could sue him for this?
• OutOfHere
  It could be worse. They could conceivably resell some your credits to pay themselves a salary.
• heliumtera
  >let someone else use your tokens >someone else use your tokenshow could this be prevented?
• malfist
  So, not only stole a bunch of money with a crypto rug pull, now stealing a bunch of money via other people's api credits?Sounds like a techbro.
• Menu

  mlmonkey
  For those of us not in the know, WTF is "Gas Town"? Please ELI5! TYVM.
• Menu

  keeganpoppen
  iono if “steal” has the right valence here