HN

Comments (75)

• Menu

  hex4def6
  Hmmm.Looking at: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article/figure?id=10.1371/...I'm not sure I believe the graphs.For example, here's another frequency response chart of some stethoscopes: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/a-Frequency-response-of-...How is it that professional stethoscopes can be that different, and yet this 3D printed one can match a gold-standard one almost exactly?From what I can tell there's no audio engineering / modelling that's been done here -- It's just some crude openSCAD tubes. And it's not even optimized for 3D printing; a 3D printed tube with a circular cross-section is going to have bridging issues at the top which will result in internal roughness. I have to imagine that results in attenuation. (A better internal shape for a tube is something that looks like "ô". The ^ will print much better)The type of plastic used and its frequency response, the thickness / stiffness of the silicone tubing, the height / width of the bell... There are so many variables that I think would make significant differences in performance. The fact that they see basically no difference is highly suspect.This feels like one of those "3D-print everything" fads that was popular a few years ago. Yes, you can make a 3D-printed adjustable wrench, but even the most miserable dollar-tree metal version will beat it in every possible metric.Likewise, on Alibaba, if you order 200 pieces, I'm seeing metal ones as low as $1.22/pc. I don't believe that this 3D printed one will even be as good as those.
• Menu

  stronglikedan
  The thing is that I can get just as good if not better ones (metal) for $7 all day long, and not have to spend time sourcing and assembling materials, and I don't even have to leave my house to do it.
• Menu

  krispykrem
  Here is an interview with one of the researchers behind this project:https://logicmag.io/bodies/tarek-loubani-on-3d-printing-in-g...It explains the project and its motivations. It's been a while since I read it (2019), but at the time I found it really fascinating and inspiring.
• Menu

  colinbartlett
  I was shocked to see that a "brand name" stethoscope is $100+ and even generic ones are $30.
• abdullahkhalids
  What's the price per use compared to a standard industrial metal one?
• hereme888
  What we need now is open-source ultrasound devices.
• Menu

  samantha_greene
  No pictures? Missed opportunity. Seems cool though!
• Menu

  Modified3019
  Do the design and materials take into account how well it can be sterilized?
• KnuthIsGod
  I can buy cheap ones online from Temu for $3.However I am comfortable with my Littmann.Littmann's last for 20 plus years.
• Menu

  ErroneousBosh
  https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/264691582901(if eBay kills that link, then for future HNers it's a link to an inexpensive bright yellow single-use plastic stethoscope by a company called Valuemed, which have been available basically forever and are for when you cannot risk getting something nasty on your good Littman)£1.99 in single unit quantities from a dude on eBay.These things are so cheap in bulk that they'd ship two in every box of Orthogon Gemini microwave links that I used to fit something like 20 years ago before VDSL was a thing to link fast sites to places that'd otherwise be on dialup. They emitted a quiet beeping to help you align them when they were in aiming mode; the cheap plastic stethoscope made it possible to hear that over wind noise, air handling units, and other such clatter.I still have a box full of them, despite giving a bunch to the nursery my son went a couple of years ago.What's the point in 3D printing something for $3 when you can buy them in a bulk box for a tenth of that?
• jader201
  Instructional video: https://youtu.be/u-KNTc0POLA
• sandworm101
  I seem to remember a major issue re 3d-printing medical things. Early in the pandemic LTT organied an effort to print some PPE face shields for hospitals. It was all rejected. The microscopic holes left in the print material meant it could not be properly sanitized.A stethoscope touches both patients and providers. This may be a place where smooth non-printed material may be the only sanitary choice.
• Menu

  brcmthrowaway
  Are sthethoscopes passive or active devices?
• onetokeoverthe
  [dead]