HN

Need help?
<- Back
Shadcn/UI now defaults to Base UI instead of Radix

Shadcn/UI now defaults to Base UI instead of Radix

dabinat

Comments (97)

  • ricardobeat
    It’s getting tiring to hear at this point, but the Claude voice comes through clearly in this post, and it’s a little off-putting. If even an important product release doesn’t warrant full human attention, where will we draw the line?
  • chvid
    For boring applications - do people prefer the copy paste approach of shadcn instead of a traditional ui library like mantine?The copy paste approach may be easily modifiable but creates new problems - ie now there is an upgrade ai agent for something that should just be ticking up a version number.
  • gherkinnn
    I have used and mostly like Shadcn, and yet their Radix-based radio button was a bit much, as are other choices, where similarly overblown solutions were used.https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46688971
  • dyllon
    Moving away from codemods and towards LLMs doing migration work is an interesting development.Even if they’re more deterministic, I wonder if the days of codemods are numbered.
  • 8cvor6j844qw_d6
    What is the shadcn/ui equivalent for Angular?PrimeNG had a licensing change recently and I'm looking at a suitable alternatives for a fresh project.
  • klaussilveira
    I miss a good old skeuomorphic styleguide. I guess the last one was Blueprint?
  • rplnt
  • pgisapedo
    Shadcn is great until you want to use it
  • vmware508
  • Topfi
    That's great. Started using Base UI early on via 9ui [0] and found the primitives very pleasant to work with, especially if one wants to compose more complex components from other Base UI components. Maybe Shad can reduce some of the dependencies they rely on now.[0] https://www.9ui.dev
  • anon
    undefined
  • nullbio
    Why? What advantage does it bring?
  • vjeux
    Curious if anyone tried Astryx that was open sourced by Meta last week to see how it compares.
  • TheFuzzball
    Imagine building a brand new component library to replace your already quite successful component library and still making it React-only.
  • kcrwfrd_
    Tangential but does anyone an have opinion on Base UI vs React Aria?Trying to decide between the two atm.
  • ruguo
    Most of the websites I found are still on the radix version.
  • joel_liu
    [flagged]
  • anon
    undefined
  • joel_liu
    [flagged]
  • saaskitdev
    [dead]
  • mr-karan
    [flagged]
  • skeptrune
    based
  • upmostly
    Great news. I've found that no UI library comes close to shadcn's quality.It even looks incredible when building desktop apps. We used it to build DB Pro [1] and the DB Pro website, and everyone compliments us on our design.I see it becoming the defacto choice for UIs especially when building with agents.[1] https://dbpro.app