HN

Comments (11)

• giancarlostoro
  The word "AI-Powered" is shown on the front-page of this project as such:An AI-powered platform for developers to "forge" rigorous and precise system specifications through an iterative process of formalization and analysis.https://imiron.io/specforge/This title should maybe include that so people are aware that if you adopt this tool, there is some expectation that AI is involved, unless it's an AI optional product, then they need to clarify.
• anon
  undefined
• itomato
  Whose formalities? The horse still comes first.
• abbasov_murad
  This method is certainly good to learn, but I had some difficulties understanding it
• Menu

  effnorwood
  SCRUM is that my PRD you?
• esafak
  From what I gather this marries a self-correcting formal specification based on Signal Temporal Logic (cf. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporal_logic) with a natural language requirement definition (like OpenSpec).STL is a spec for continuous, real-time signals over dense time that is appropriate for physical devices and real-time streams. See the "Use Cases for Integration" section in their landing page: https://imiron.io/specforge/If I were them I would lead with how they differ from existing spec languages.
• Menu

  OutOfHere
  I have been thinking about how to write specifications for an AI agent to write code for a new project with detailed requirements. I was simply going write it as a list of requirements, starting at REQ001, one beneath the other, with subsequent requirements also building upon prior ones. The developed code would be intended to mark as a comment where in the code each individual requirement is implemented. There might also exist one primary unit test for each requirement. If tests are to not be implemented, then a human is more closely responsible for reviewing changes to the implementation. Over time, I would update/insert/delete individual requirements, and gaps may come to exist in their numbering, but this is okay. The numbers are sorted identifiers only, so a new requirement can even be added as say REQ033B. Overall, this is not a formal system, and it's loose enough that any human and any AI can work with it. For a formal system, an AI may even translate my prose into a formal definition language that it is familiar with, of which there are many. In conclusion, I don't think it's the job of a human to write specifications in a formal spec language.
• poslathian
  Nice, very LTL
• Menu

  IshKebab
  Strong SVA vibes. Also it seems to be only free for non-commercial use. Interesting anyway!