HN

Comments (94)

• Menu

  ahmadyan
  Congrats to Can on the pre-seed funding. genuinely wishing you all the best.The terminal multiplexer / multi-agent coding space is getting very crowded. YC alone has funded many competing startups in this space: herdr, Superset, cmux, Emdash, Orca, Bullet, Conductor (Conductor was in YC before pivoting from chat->coding). I’m probably missing a few, and that’s before counting companies outside YC such as Superlogical and Agentastic.dev (by yours truly).One thing I find particularly interesting is the role of open source in this market.A lot of these products started open source (i assume as a tactical way to gain traction and build a community). But after the early traction phase or raise funding, the incentives seem to change.Being open source by itself is not a product differentiator in this market. The features required for string positioning (orchestration, cloud, custom agents, enterprise features, hosted infrastructure, etc.) often end up either closed source or available only through the hosted product.That makes me wonder how much developers actually value OSS for this category. How much does it matter to you whether your IDE or coding environment is open source?Is OSS important because you want to inspect the code, fork it, self-host it, avoid vendor lock-in, or simply because you trust open-source developer tools more? Or, for desktop software like IDEs is open source mostly a nice-to-have rather than a requirement? So I’m curious where HN lands on this
• Taek
  This title is killing me. "The runtime stays open" is such a heavy, attention grabbing sentence, it's all I can stare at on the front page. It's the type of writing that makes me hate working with LLMs, because it's so powerful at monopolizing my attention, and makes it difficult for me to focus on any of the other words on the page (whether the front page, or the comments page).
• Menu

  ValentineC
  > That’s why I recently switched it from AGPL to Apache: I want everyone to use Herdr freely, without any problem.I'm curious what the actual problems with AGPL were.
• abofh
  You've joined an accelerator, not gone public, of course you're not ready to rug pull
• Menu

  user-
  Congrats to Can! I am using Herdr and i think its a great tool. A modern solo dev success story , very inspirational.I see some negative comments here that I could understand why funding scares them when it comes to their open source tool but like.. atleast congratulate the guy.
• Menu

  asadm
  I am guessing this now directly competes with mitchellh's multiplexer / Superlogical.
• Menu

  humblepie
  Okay, back to tmux it is then.
• loveparade
  Oh no, I was using it. What's a good replacement? Guess I'll go back to tmux.
• jdorfman
  Congrats Can. Love your product, it has become the default way to orchestrate agents in my terminal.
• kristjansson
  As a relatively recent herdr user, I’ll say (1) congratulations and (2) the thing that was most attractive was the seeming orthogonality of the tool. It sits apart, interfaces with subordinate programs in a few clearly delineated ways, and integrates them only as much as the user desires. Critically, “no integration just show me the terminal output of my program” is an option, and a useful one!I appreciate that discipline and respect for your user in the current tool, and hope to be a paying customer of a similarly values-aligned business you’ll build on top of it!
• lonesword
  Congratulations! I came across herdr a few weeks ago and I've been daily driving it ever since. I've tried a few other tools like Emdash and Superset but Herdr is the only one that did a decent job rendering Claude code UI and didn't randomly crash and could run on a remote server.
• Menu

  vehemenz
  I've been using Herdr for a while now, but I'd like a multiplexer that's also a meta-harness that I can connect to remotely. I know others have setups that work, I just haven't quite figured it out yet.
• hx8
  I switched from tmux to Herdr about six weeks ago. It's a great bit of software, the UI is focused on switching between multiple agents quickly. I run Herdr to keep my opencode instances well managed, and it also works great for having a few terminals opens next to your agent. I find myself keeping opencode sessions open for longer like what happens with Codex and Claude code, which is great if I need to revisit a context to do some follow up work. I'm genuinely excited to see if the creators can bring even more value to the application.If you're worried about enshittification I wouldn't be. It's relatively basic open source software that runs locally. A perfect candidate for a fork if the base app starts degrading.
• Menu

  ernsheong
  Ironically a lot of YC hate despite the fact that we are literally in their forum.
• behole
  Congrats on momentum! Well earned. Love Herdr.
• Menu

  Gooblebrai
  I thought the A2A protocol from Google would solve this of our personal agents speaking with company agents
• Waterluvian
  I haven’t seen one of those classic Herdr/Herdly tech names in a while now.
• kar1181
  Oh man - herdr is great. This will not be net good. Sigh.
• Menu

  nlh
  I am a HUGE herdr fan - discovered it a few months ago and it's exactly what I need for my workflow. Thousands of others have discovered it as well, which is awesome.I have such mixed feelings about this - YC means VC means commercialization means enshitification. I really wish that weren't the case, but it so very often is.Here's hoping this one's different...(PS I am a big YC fan in general! I don't mean to sound anti-YC or anti-VC or anti-capitalism. But when it comes to low-level essential development tools, I'll never forget what happened to Warp, which started out as such a nice clean terminal project and turned into an absolute money-chasing mess.)
• foxtrot8672
  could just host it on the cloud?
• Menu

  dominotw
  wtf is "runtime"
• tyleo
  Tbh it doesn’t bother me entirely. I love this tool so much I’d pay for it.VC funding can enshitify things but it can also improve them. Here’s hoping for the latter.
• throwaway613746
  [dead]
• barapa
  [flagged]
• Menu

  EGreg
  Wow, congrats! Can you discuss how you got YCombinator to select your open source project? I know they sometimes fund open source… I’ve been building several large platforms since 2011 but I have never considered applying like that.Would something like this qualify:https://github.com/Qbixhttps://github.com/Intercoinhttps://github.com/Safebots/Safecloud
• Menu

  rvz
  Quick question: Would you have actually donated to Herdr if they were asking for donations? I don't think any of you would have, unless stated otherwise.So this is another reason why developers do not pay for their tools and instead the developers of these tools go to VCs anyway. It's not the fault of the author, but most of the users (developers themselves) always want their tools for free at $0.You have to pay and support the tools you use or else the VCs will do it for you so you can't complain when scenarios like this keep happening.