HN

Comments (247)

• Menu

  rpdillon
  LG's statement:> ACR uses audio fingerprinting technology using the TV’s internal audio processor (not a speaker) to identify content and does not collect screenshots, screen recordings, video recordings, voice recordings, or other audio recordings from the TV.So they are claiming that ACR is done entirely through audio processing, and no visual data from the screen itself is used? That...doesn't seem plausible.This paper from 2024 investigated both Samsung and LG and found that they both capture screen images for ACR, and send the resulting hash (not the raw content) back to the manufacturer for identification.https://arxiv.org/html/2409.06203v1We're going to have to get saavy in pulling apart the distinction between "I look at everything and then send a nice summary back to my manufacturer" and "I send everything back to my manufacturer". As AI gets cheaper and more efficient, it'll be baked into everything, and will distill signal at the edge and send the good bits back to central command. I fear the legalese in the ToS will obscure this new way of "not collecting" user information.
• Menu

  zephyreon
  > Features such as Automatic Content Recognition (ACR), voice recognition, and interest-based advertising are optional. These features are not enabled by default. Users can choose to enable these features and can manage or withdraw consent through TV settings.They may be optional features but I’m pretty sure when I set up my tv and got to the screen where you are required to agree to the various terms and privacy legalese the “happy path” was to hit the “accept all” button vs use the remote to navigate into each one, read, and only activate the few required to use the tv. I would not call this dark pattern “optional” by default.
• Menu

  aeternum
  Note that their statement could also be true if they record 99% of the time. We need to start calling companies out for meaningless weasel statements like "We don't record continuously".The majority of the problem is also simply the ability to record. Putting a remote control listening hardware on a device that runs a plethora of 3rd party apps and with full connection to the internet means that even if LG isn't controlling that mic, someone else will be.
• Menu

  dang
  Recent and related:LG TVs caught spying even when offline or on standby - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49612329 - Sept 2026 (359 comments)GamersNexus and LG: Or why rooting your TV is a bad idea - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49605424 - Sept 2026 (133 comments)A Screensaver for LG's Spying Smart TVs - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49605356 - Sept 2026 (13 comments)LG TVs aren't the only ones spying on you [video] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49575176 - Sept 2026 (18 comments)
• Menu

  al_borland
  They say these features are opt-in and they reject dark patterns, but in my experience setting up LG TVs, everything was opt-in and I had to manually hunt through all the menus to turn this stuff off.Their statements don’t align with the reality I’ve experienced as a customer. My TV is not connected to the network, because the setup process left me with 0 trust that LG wouldn’t be collecting information regardless of my settings, or that I didn’t miss something. There was also the risk that they’d add a new “feature” with an update which would I’d be automatically opted in to.Until they start selling truly dumb TVs, I’m not going to trust anything and their statements fall flat.
• Menu

  bryan0
  > "LG TVs process voice data only when the voice button on the remote control is pressed and held, or when a wake word such as 'Hi LG' is recognized after the user has activated the Far-Field voice recognition feature."> LG went on to say that beyond the aforementioned instances, "the TVs do not collect or record ambient conversations."LG is contradicting themselves here. In order to detect a wake word then they must be collecting or recording ambient conversations.I think the main questions are:1. Is it fully supported to use LG TVs disconnected from the internet.2. Are wake word voice controls and ACR truly opt-in. They claim it is in the statement but (as others have mentioned) I remain skeptical what definition of “opt-in” they are using.Update: some of this is becoming a semantic discussion on the definitions of “recording” and “collecting”, but to circumvent this I would say:If a device can detect words in my ambient conversations and depending on what it detects (accurate or not) it can send that audio to the cloud, I would describe that device as “collecting or recording ambient conversations”
• Menu

  seanalltogether
  ACR is "not enabled by default"? Is this actually true or is it one of those weasley technicalities where the tv ships with it turned off, but once you connect the tv to the internet it turns on?
• Menu

  firefoxd
  "We own the glass" that's what really stood out to me. I can still disconnect my TV from wifi. But what scares me is when every device comes with their own esim and cellular radio.
• Menu

  mordae
  Remember that one time when music CDs from Sony MBG installed a rootkit on your PC that continuously sent whatever MP3s you had on your PC back to them?
• HelloUsername
  Change url to source? https://www.lg.com/global/newsroom/news/statements/statement...Also they provided a statement earlier to Gizmodo: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49628328
• Terr_
  A quixotic legal dream: All consumer data-surveillance must take the form of an opt-in monthly payment plan, which either side can cancel.So the TV gets advertised as "$$$, but basically $$ if you sign up to be surveilled and get a $/month check back." If the company sets $/month too low--or is too creepy about what they collect--people just won't opt-in.But what happens if they promise big pay-backs but routinely cancel from their side? That's a problem, but at least it's a kind "the market" can handle when it comes to reputation and bad reviews.
• Menu

  runjake
  > "LG also said that its features like “Automatic Content Recognition (ACR), voice recognition, and interest-based advertising are optional,” and “not enabled by default.”I am absolutely certain that ACR was enabled on our new TV by default, back some years ago. I am nearly certain their voice recognition, and advertising spying were enabled on our TV by default.If none of this is truly "enabled by default" then this is a recent development.I discovered this many years ago and did some deep dives, and unfortunately didn't publish anything about it. Lesson learned.
• Menu

  jasonkhanlar
  "LG Says We're Fake News" - Gamers Nexus https://youtu.be/ToP9xfLDSME
• calmworm
  And Michael Scott declares bankruptcy. Newsworthy?
• rr808
  Everyone complains but realistically TVs are so incredibly cheap now, I can't believe anyone would make money from hardware alone. I mean a Samsung 55in 4k tv for $300 delivered for free is crazy, let alone the $179 insignia one.
• beloch
  LG’s Approach to PrivacyOur approach is guided by four principles:Transparency – Helping users understand how smart TV features work and how related data may be used.User Choice – Giving users meaningful control over optional features and services.Informed Consent – Supporting informed decisions through clear and manageable consent choices.Continuous Improvement – Continuously improving privacy controls, transparency, and security protections.--------------------Transparency:This document isn't terribly easy to understand by the standards of traditional TV's. You have to pay close attention to figure out what is and isn't going on, and when. It also should have been taped to the front of every LG TV when it comes out of the box.User Choice:There is extensive explanation of how what LG TV's are doing isn't nefarious, but the fact remains that there's no switch to turn it off. Why not just put a simple hardware on/off switch on these TV"s to turn off all connectivity? Maybe some users want dumb TV's, or maybe they just don't want to worry about all of this.Informed Consent:Buyers apparently consented to this at the store. Now you're finally informing them. That's now how informed consent works.Continuous Improvement:I'll believe LG and other Smart TV manufacturers are serious about this when they add a hardware wifi on/off switch, and not a moment before.
• DenisM
  For practical fixes, consider replacing the TV with a “commercial monitor” and connecting an Apple TV device instead (or an open source thingy).Disconnecting “smart tv” from internet to use Apple TV is possible and might work, but you will get nagged to reconnect all the time. And TV mfr will eventually try to find workarounds - purchase access to wireless connections from large-footprint connectivity providers (Xfinity WIFI, 4g/5g networks, etc) or create a p2p network among their own connected devices. I doubt they do it right now as it’s less profitable to focus on niche audience, but eventually it might become profitable enough.
• nottorp
  They can be trusted as much as Sony and game ownership i suppose.I still have an 1080p TV because I can't be arsed to do the research on what 4k TV won't spy on me.It helps that most "content" isn't worth 4k anyway.
• Menu

  heaney-555
  I simply don't connect any TV to the internet.Instead, I connect a Google TV Streamer, as I'm in the Google ecosystem. For my friends in the Apple ecosystem, I tell them to do the same with an Apple TV box.
• pastor_williams
  If you live in the United States you should find out who your state senator and representative are and write a letter to them asking them to propose, and support legislation prohibiting spying and increasing consumer privacy protection.Kentucky passed HB 692 unanimously requiring smart TVs to ask permission if they are going to be spying on us. Ask your state legislature to follow their lead and pass some very popular consumer privacy protection.
• algoth1
  What was the alternative? "LG admits to spying claims, execs align to be arrested asap"
• Menu

  Koshcheiushko
  I've one question: I've used android phone (realme, which is chinese). And i remember that whenever we used to discuss somethings among our friends, i started used to get ads realated to that on my laptop, phone within atmost a hour.So, was realme transcribing all conversations and uploading it? Can someone answer?
• drnick1
  If you have one of those TVs, disassemble it and unplug or remove the microphone, camera and the wireless adapter. Use it as a (rather nice) 4K monitor for a Linux box with Plasma in Bigscreen mode. Pair that with an airmouse remote and you get the most private and user-centric streaming/gaming platform that you can build. Put a decent GPU in the box, add an Xbox controller and Steam and you also built the world's best console.
• Menu

  zug_zug
  We need to start using AI to hack our own devices and make our own TV os, sort of like was done for routers. Probably relatively doable these days.
• anon
  undefined
• dabeeeenster
  "Nearby sounds or speech occurring at the same time as a user's command may sometimes appear in speech-recognition results.""Do not continuously record or transmit"Soooo....
• Daklone
  It should be noted that Gamers Nexus discovered LG TVs reach out and build a map of every device in the area.They noted the discovery traffic with Wireshark, and commented on LG boasting about how many connected devices their networks can see.This remains to be a larger issue than the clear fact LG TVs can easily be used as remote spy devices, even when offline, by wirelessly remote connected agents.
• Menu

  seanieb
  The only reason TV’s are getting cheaper is the business model changed. Now your viewing data (and perhaps conversations) are part of their product offering.
• Havoc
  That's a bold play given how "caught red handed" the gamersnexus video was.
• Oh-Kay_Labs
  easy to prove. Open source your stuff LG.
• anon
  undefined
• anon
  undefined
• Menu

  initramfs
  https://www.youtube.com/shorts/-KgX9xyIRK8 "Can the CIA really spy on your phone?" He mentions TV and while it's off.
• jarym
  The real issue here is they’ve been dishonest and less than candid with their customers.Trust broken, words out, and their statement doesn’t really do anything to mending that.
• Menu

  androiddrew
  How can we lock down a TV, still use it but trust we aren't being spied on?
• lousken
  Maybe they should have shorter and clearer terms? Maybe it should be easy to just opt out?
• jodydonetti
  Obligatory referencehttps://youtu.be/krj5NM-6tfU
• Jcampuzano2
  > Audio used for wake-word detection is processed locally on the TV and, if no wake word is detected, audio is not converted to text, stored, or transmitted. Voice-recognition results and related technical logs may be generated as part of processing a voice command. These records are associated with specific voice interactions and do not indicate continuous recording of conversations occurring outside an active voice recognition session.From their statement. This entire thing is contradictory. You cannot both say "not converted to text, stored, or transmitted", while at the same time saying the results may be generated and stored in the form of logs.We need to hold companies responsible for this shit.
• tombardier
  I for one completely believe them. That's why I rooted my C5, disabled all telemetry, and disabled Internet access entirely by default from an isolated vlan on my network that has no access to anything on any other network. I'm tempted to remove the WiFi/BT board if it's an add-on card, and probably unplug the microphones as well. I only need it as a display for my PC and 4K disc player.
• tracerbulletx
  The leaked advertising pitch videos from them where they say "we own the glass" as a pitch to potential advertising partners, about a tv they sold me just viscerally pissed me off so I'm kind of just done with them even if thats an irrationally strong response. The whole attitude just makes me so mad.
• Menu

  zoobab
  GDPR is forcing them to detail which private data they collect.
• Menu

  illusive4080
  Easy solution. Do not connect your TV to the internet.
• WesolyKubeczek
  Imagine here the goose and a jacket guy meme, where the goose says "Why then you have so many microphones in it? Why so many microphones!?"
• Menu

  Neywiny
  Bold from the verge, as clicking the link to go to the official statement took me through 3 redirect trackers as picked up by my browser/extensions (I think ubo to be specific)
• someonehere
  The ACR stuff was turned on by default for mine. They are straight up lying.
• xyst
  lg trying to spin this so hard the earth rotation may stop
• Joel_Mckay
  Creepy spyware vendor insists they aren't doing what they were caught doing.They made customers feel like suckers for trusting the Brand.Their LG logo was literally on the signed evidence. What a bunch of clowns getting exposed by community reporters. Thanks Steve. =3
• Simulacra
  So very strange every time I visit Tomshardware.com, I get a pop-up on my iPhone that asked me "Do you want to download "sync-pixel" on "usync.ingage.tech"?What is that? And why does it only happen on that website?
• mohamedkoubaa
  We need a push notification: "Living room TV wants to use its microphone" and for it to be locked out if you don't allow it.
• j45
  Leaving TVs disconnected from the internet is the only way to ignore this.Connect your own devices and smarts to it.A broader issue is that it does any kind of recording, or processing of the signals around the tv (from a microphone) or what is displayed on the tv (image) is both extremely private.Privacy has been violated by LG according to their own wording. a way that is not controlled by settings.What might LG want with an anonymized hash of the audio being played or shown on someone's screen?Existing ad matching technology can link it with the video of what you're watching to build a shadow profile of you and then sell the attention of your eyeballs to advertising.From there, simply what you watch, at what time, for how long roughly sets up a wonderful demographic of age, gender, interests, and all that fun stuff. This is an area of tv and video advertisign that has existed for a long time including online and cable tv boxes.LG's statement that it doesn't move your info anywhere about what is being watched via audio seems to be a variant of this. Using the audio fingerprint, their software could request an ad for it from another system and direction.So your information may not leave the TV indirectly, but thsi type of a mechanism does exist in cable tv boxes, etc.With TVs absorbing the OTT (set top box) functions they are absorbing this too so their claims of how big their market is probably tied to being able to sell advertising into that ecosystem.It’s likely an unadvertised function only for the benefit and leverage of LG and may be buried in signing your life away to use their “smart” tv functions as well.A tiny crack in LG tvs can be an attack vector for security and safety. Whether it's audio, or video, or anything.The best TV is a dumb tv, with all internet disabled and plug in your own smarts that you can hopefully manage better.A brand is a promise of an experience. This brand has broken a promise and it can’t be pretending it didn’t.
• JohnMakin
  Wolf claims they are utterly interested in eating sheep, news at 11
• bediger4000
  So what? We allow people and corporations to lie under almost all circumstances, including most ads and press releases. Get them under oath, if they still deny spying, that would be a minor news item.
• adar2378
  damn LG doing what now!
• TZubiri
  Sounds like these TVs will not get much sales in the US and they will be put on sale at a discount in countries with a lower gdp per capita.I.e: these will probably trickle down to me
• yieldcrv
  yeah but what about third party analytics packages that may be abusing enterprising or privileged credentialsI think this is all disingenuous and will stay that way until the public asks the right questions to the right peoplethe CEO of the obvious organization can go in front of Congress and truthfully say “Senator, we are not listening, targeting is based on browsing patterns and data brokers”while the targeted ads and timelines remain based on all those other inputs, and also audio
• txheilmann
  [flagged]
• zosoworld
  [dead]
• tedggh
  [flagged]
• TeaVMFan
  [flagged]
• kwarcode
  [dead]
• 0utcast
  [dead]
• surcap526
  [dead]