<- Back
Comments (73)
- linuxhanslOff-topic and somewhat of a rant, but I'd far prefer us all focusing on open standards like HIP, SYCL, OpenCL, etc.It's unbearable that most LLM inference happens on closed H/W, closed drivers, and closed SDKs.
- swernerAI will take down Nvidia’s moat. When it becomes trivial to translate CUDA/PTX to HIP, SYCL or Metal, CUDA is no longer the moat, it becomes the intermediate representation.
- triwatsInteresting option for CDNA architecture chips. I wonder if this moves to an open standard?AMD GPUs build for AI specs for reference: https://flopper.io/gpus?vendor=AMD&page=1
- lulzxI made cuda-metal btw (for mac kek), https://github.com/lulzx/cuda-metal
- KennyBlankenTo save everyone a click: No cuDNN and based off an ancient version of ROCm for windows (7.1 has been out for ages, 7.2 is current.)
- Nuryssoman i can't say how much i used to like cuda when i had a nvidia gpu it made ml so much fun and on amd its a war especially on rdna 2 cards which i have. hopefully one day we will be able to properly translate cuda for its amd counter parts
- system2I wish there were a way to use RDNA1 cards with CUDA for AMD. My 5700XTs are sitting in a drawer.
- latchkeyThere are also interesting efforts like:https://github.com/Zaneham/Boothhttps://scale-lang.com/
- chiassedu80CUDA for AMD on WindowsI’ve been working on a Windows setup that lets CUDA-targeted applications run on AMD GPUs using ZLUDA + ROCm/HIP.Repo: https://github.com/Speedstu/CUDA-for-AMD-WindowsSo far, it has only been tested on my RX 9060 XT (gfx1200), where I’ve used it with CUDA-enabled LibTorch workloads, including long ai training and use.I also added a GPU scanner / auto-detection system that detects:AMD GPU modelgfxXXXX architectureROCm/HIP installationdriver infowhether the GPU has already been validated by the projectExample:RX 9060 XT → gfx1200 → RDNA4 → HIP detected → validatedThe goal now is to test it on more hardware, especially RX 6000 / 7000 / 9000 cards.If you have an AMD GPU on Windows and want to try it, I’d really appreciate compatibility reports working or broken. There’s a dedicated GPU compatibility issue template in the repo.If this is useful to you, a star would also help the project get more testers.