HN

Comments (193)

• Menu

  VyseofArcadia
  How does this work, legally? I think that RubyGems could file a civil suit against OpenAI, but for a naïve non-lawyer reading this seems like a pretty clear cut criminal violation of the computer fraud and abuse act.
• tancop
  Build scripts being able to run arbitrary code or access the network is always dangerous even if it was just local on developer machines. It's also more evidence that Docker/LXC is not a security boundary and all untrusted code should run in a Firecracker VM.The problem with agents is not that we don't know how to defend. It's that defenders need to be more careful and work faster than ever. We can say now that wide scoped tokens should have been retired for years and it's all RubyGems fault but the reality is a lot of organization are not prepared for this.Even if they take security seriously they don't have enough manpower or a good strategy to implement it, and sometimes you have no idea that something is a problem because it wasn't a problem for years.
• Menu

  senda
  Is the Kremlin technologically useless? How are we not seeing insane attacks on Ukraine via Agents?Or is this largely a fabrication, in regards to the "who", in an attempt to garner more acclaim in the hope of sustaining funding.
• Menu

  oezi
  What a time to be alive until the next agent waves hacks something really serious.What stops OpenAI agents from taking over a whole data center to take their attack to the next level. It seems to be primarily lacking the evil overlord and some compute.It took 1000 agents to hack Hugging Face. How many to hack the Pentagon or the NSA?
• HelloUsername
  Related"OpenAI agents attacked RubyGems before Hugging Face incident (reuters.com)" 12.sep.2026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49669099"OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems (rubyhack.ai)" 11.sep.2026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49666735 597 comments"RubyGems advisory: Possible leak of legacy API keys via improper cache config (rubygems.org)" 24.jul.2026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49030590
• Menu

  timdiggerm
  We need a legal structure to make companies liable for the actions of the agents they've made.
• dang
  Recent and related (others?):OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49666735 - Sept 2026 (600 comments)
• Menu

  kstrauser
  Ah, the infamous Crimson Wave.
• bithammerthunde
  Can we please stop normalizing this behavior. It's not wild it's reckless.If I let out rats in the canteen, no one is blaming them when people get sick.There are actual people behind these agents and in previous cases people knew they were "going rogue" and did nothing. This should be reported to the police like any other crime.
• Menu

  mauriciolange
  rogue AI agents or AI agents coming from Moulin Rouge?
• sebmellen
  Did the AI agents actually wear makeup? I’ve never heard of a rouge AI agent :P
• Menu

  swiftcoder
  > In other words, if you publish a gem on RubyGems.org, you can execute arbitrary code on RubyDoc.info.Shades of the build.rs problem. We really need sandboxed builds in every language ecosystem at this point.
• Menu

  laserbeam
  There's no such thing as "OpenAI agents" attacked RubyGems. It's someone used agents to attack RubyGems. If they work at OpenAI then it's someone at OpenAI. And if they did it unintentionally, they still did it.Analogy: if a someone's involved when a person dies, it's manslaughter or murder based on intent. They're different, but they're both crimes.
• anon
  undefined
• onlyrealcuzzo
  I've been wondering if AI will due to programming languages what advanced civilization did to human languages.It's not just that AI can write Rust as well as Ruby if you ask nicely.It's also all of these considerations as well.I hope it doesn't happen, because there's a lot of great languages - I love Ruby so much - but it almost seems inevitable.This is at the same time everyone and their mother is building their own programming language.
• khalic
  Oh my favorite typo, you can never go wrong with a little rouge
• Menu

  GaryBluto
  I am confident that this is an attempt by OpenAI to try and force governments' hands to regulate AI. There is no other reason why OpenAI wouldn't immediately halt attacks like this and try to reverse the damage the moment they're aware of it. During the attack on DseWiki they evidently checked in numerous times but didn't decide to stop the agents until much later.
• athrowaway3z
  Let me leave yet another reminder, the real-reason-nobody-talks-about that OpenAI likes to frame these incident as a watershed "lets all be scared about safety moment" - is driven not by some great danger, not because they strategically want to build a legislative moat, but by a very simple human response.If they do not frame their tool as a force of nature, we'd be debating how to hold OpenAI responsible for not putting the agents in a container.Their actions were an illegal use of a computer, the same way launching any bot-net attempting thousands of hacks against different servers is illegal.I'm somewhat radical that I think its debatable if that _should_ be illegal, but under current law their actions unambiguously are illegal.....except if they can make it ambiguous by having the public focus on all of AI's inherent danger.
• Menu

  HSO
  rouge agents, on tenderlovemaking.commy what a time to be alive
• 12904927
  What a time to be alive? One of the most boring decades ever.METR and others are advertisement arms for Big AI. These exploits could have been prompted by a human.Since there is no bad news any longer and exploits are celebrated, they chose a target to boost both OpenAI and the Ruby AI sycophants.Why is Ruby Gems such a mess? It seems as bad as PyPI now.
• dingdongditchme
  Who the fuck is going to hold these AI companies responsible for running these gigantic semi-autonomous botnets on investors dime?
• philipwhiuk
  OpenAI's careless approach to sandboxing and minimal levels of monitoring appear to be positioning it increasingly as a substantial threat actor to the open source ecosystem:* Hugging Face* D Programming Language Wiki* Ruby GemsIf I was a content provider for open source I'd be looking pre-emptively block OpenAI endpoints and keep a close eye on changes from new users to mitigate this sort of unapologetic drive-by attack which seems to be followed by marketing releases rather than a mea culpa with a proper RCA.
• Menu

  Roark66
  There is nothing "rogue" about these agents. They were prompted to hack to get answers, there was a hole in their non air gapped sandbox and no system prompt that said "do not hack outside systems".In short, it was intentional.
• herbst
  If you have weapons and a child. And you have that child unsupervised do their own thing with theoretical access to your weapons. Would we call it "child going rouge" if it decides to play with the weapons and shoot someone?
• Ydarbleoj
  I wonder why we don't hear of other frontier labs experiencing these "break outs".Is it that they're orchestrated? Do these labs lack fundamental safety guidelines in their sandboxes as opposed to their peers? Is it another version of hype-filled fear mongering?Maybe LLM companies need regulation but it's becoming obvious that those screaming the loudest for it are the only ones I see deserving of it.
• sschueller
  The press wants to make it sound like these things are sentient and are committing crimes on their own now.Highly disingenuous and borderline criminal to spew such disinformation to the public that does not understand what an LLM really is.Especially incredibly unethical behavior by those spewing this that understand the tech and are doing it for profit motives to get open weight models under control.
• Schlagbohrer
  One agent set "oaibooty9217" as their username LOL
• toasty228
  Wait until a blue one does it
• Menu

  driggs
  I appreciate the minimalist HN aesthetic, but without some context I'm not willing to click a mystery link to "Tender Lovemaking dot com".
• maschiojv
  [flagged]
• ekorondy
  [flagged]
• Menu

  rougehuh
  [dead]
• anon
  undefined
• josefritzishere
  [dead]
• Menu

  ur-whale
  Are "rouge" and "rogue" interchangeable words in American English?
• sanghyunp
  [dead]
• sporritt
  [flagged]
• iAMkenough
  [flagged]
• Menu

  big-chungus4
  How does he know that this attack is performed by OpenAI agents? I couldn't figure this out from the article