HN

Comments (115)

• Menu

  claiir
  > The launch is checked rather than trusted.Damn even Nvidia is putting out fully Claude-written articles.
• Menu

  jacobgorm
  I strongly dislike CUDA. Once you have allowed that proprietary cr*p into your C++ codebase, it is very hard to get rid, and you end up with code that is either tied to a single vendor or an #ifdef hell, probably both.The best way to program GPUs is face up to the reality that they are not the same machine as the CPU, write your kernels in separate files, and launch them manually, like in Metal, OpenCL, and D3D12, etc. These days we even have DSLs like Triton that make kernel writing much more ergonomic than anything you would hope to achieve in Rust.
• Menu

  dllu
  Since NVIDIA owns huggingface now and huggingface has the excellent Candle [1] crate for inference on Rust, this seems like a good step towards nice native Rust kernels.[1] https://github.com/huggingface/candle
• winwang
  Really exciting but it reads like Claude instead of what Nvidia posts have generally been like in the past. I don't need nor want my tech blogs to sound like a young adult novel.
• Menu

  LarsDu88
  In this age of LLM written everything which has softly killed my motivation for learning Rust somewhat, this has revived my interest if not only for the fact the LLMs haven't yet been trained on this yet!
• Menu

  manyatoms
  How does this compare to vectorware? (https://www.vectorware.com/blog/)
• nullbio
  Makes me sad that Go doesn't get love. I feel like Go is perfect for LLMs.
• evaltoken
  Interesting direction from Nvidia. Anything that makes writing reliable GPU code less painful is definitely a good thing.
• Driftbench
  Been waiting for something like this. CUDA C++ is a pain; Rust's safety for kernel programming could be a game changer.
• Menu

  the__alchemist
  I'm looking forward to trying these when they stabilize! I currently use WGPU for graphics, and cudarc for CUDA.Note: Cuda-oxide is similar to Cudarc's host component, but uses a rust-style kernel dialect. Advantage: Share structs between host and device. Disadvantage: Trading standard Cuda kernels for a new, WIP dialect.I haven't tried the tile API yet; looking forward to it.The last time I checked, Cuda Oxide was Linux only, and required Async; these are why I haven't tried it yet.
• bt1a
  Will it then be possible to query TJunc hotspot temps on linux?
• rvz
  First of all, this is a pre-1.0 release that requires a nightly Rust compiler (if you choose the SIMT track with cuda-oxide) so that one is going to be unstable software.Secondly, When an issue occurs with a kernel or you want to write your own custom kernel in Rust, now we need to diagnose if the problem came from either cuda-oxide (SIMT), Rust's side, CUDA or Tile (If you decide to choose the Tile track).Another dependency into the list and course everything is open source except CUDA itself. So any issue that happens on the CUDA level, you are forced to wait for them to fix it.
• nicebyte
  what this article tells me is that no one at Nvidia actually cares about this project whatsoever. otherwise, they would have had a person actually write the announcement.
• shmerl
  Nvidia only? Typical.This is more promising: https://github.com/Rust-GPU/rust-gpu/
• mococa
  AI slop article, how can I trust on this?
• nonmaskable
  [dead]
• ReshamJoshi
  [dead]
• westurner
  [dead]
• Menu

  mococa
  The world is unsafe
• dunlin
  Rust for GPU programming? My CUDA debugging sessions just got a whole lot less painful, hopefully.