HN

Comments (58)

• Menu

  zkmon
  You can't turn a blind eye to the natural saturation of need vs solutions, and derive unlimited optimism from the fact how the people were wrong when they said "everything is already done".You can't see ideas as some isolated objects that can come into existence on their own. The overall ecosystem breeds the ideas. The forces of demand create the supply chain. Human need funds the solutions. Peace times, plenty of food give the time and effort needed for inventions. If Europe has all the science going on in the 17-19th centuries, it is not because only Europe has best minds. Europe has the people with free time, food and riches to afford the science work.You can't ignore the overall context of the world around you. You can't keep selling infinite ideas. You can't feed infinite amount of sugar to a person. The so-called solutions can turn toxic, dangerous, and unwanted things. Some ideas might be just be a package of problem and solution packed together. When you buy the solution, you receive the problem as well, which didn't exist earlier.
• erelong
  these articles are so pushy sometimes lolsometimes ideas may be harder to find and you're not a coward for saying soother times maybe not (but I'm still not sure if people are cowards for saying so)
• Menu

  jgeada
  Ideas are a dime a dozen, they've never been the interesting or limiting part of creating a real product.Knowing what is the right problem to solve, what the right idea (of many) to apply to it, and then being able to execute, delivering to the right audience, refining as necessary are the actual things that separate success from failure.
• Menu

  comrade1234
  Ideas are cheap. I remember when I decided to program full-time and get a job in the Bay Area at the beginning of the '99-'02 dotcom boom-bust. I had a good recruiter who got me lots of interviews. I'd sign the NDA and go to the interview only for it to be the same idea as the last company I talked and signed an NDA for. It was interesting to see which of these dupe companies made it and which ones failed. Most failed because only one could succeed in the space.
• fasterik
  I was surprised when I heard Tristan Buckmaster, an expert on fluid dynamics, say that we still don't understand basic things from first principles like how airplanes generate lift.https://youtu.be/PQYFRuZ5phs?si=wy8-ksarC1pVgQuT&t=5235I suspect we're always going to be in this state because every breakthrough raises new fundamental questions.
• NetOpWibby
  We’ve tricked sand into thinking, eradicated most diseases, and you’ll still see people claim with every fiber in their being, that something is impossible and someone on the other side of the world will instantaneously respond from their toilet.If you’re tired of thinking, just say that. Don’t project your middling imagination onto others.
• ks2048
  > “Ideas are getting harder to find” is a pretty bleak thing to believe. It says, “Look around the world. This is pretty much as good as it gets; the returns start diminishing from here. All the problems you see are unlikely to be solved anytime soon, so you better get used to them.” Why would anyone agree to such a thing without putting up a fight?I don't think the first quote implies the second, as claimed. The first is about scientific discovery and the second is about political and social problems.
• Menu

  kraig911
  As an engineer I'm afraid in the age of AI all the easy ideas have been found / lots of companies are working on. It's the hard ones we all know that seem to be intangible. I am still struggling to make things on the side and not feel the weight of my inner thoughts self doubting essentially on "is this juice worth the squeeze if anyone can do it?" but I keep doing it out of the supposed fun I get out of making something. Novel ideas do seem hard to come by though.
• Menu

  CM30
  This has always been a really important point:> Every discovery opens up additional discoveries to make. Which in turn lead to more discoveries.A lot of great ideas just need the right prerequisites to become possible.Makes me wonder if LLMs lowering the bar for implementing new ideas mean that future ideas that depend on said implementations will finally come into their own. Not sure what those would be, but there have to be ideas that depend on prerequisites that didn't occur because there wasn't a technical guy/team interested in implementing those prerequisites.
• Menu

  chadcmulligan
  There's a book The Creative Act - A Way of Being by Rick Rubin, he's a music producer but the ideas are general, I enjoyed it. I have enough ideas to last me a lifetime, its a pretty inspirational book, there's always something and now we have these wonderful automata to help us discover things - it's the beginning of a golden age imho.
• ThePhysicist
  It's more about attention and getting traction, with a good idea you will get some but there's just so much more noise. Look at Steam, every day so many great looking games that probably play quite well come out, honestly 5-10 years ago they would have blown my mind, now apparently every week we get a release of a game that is super polished and has great mechanics. So yeah, I love that more people can make great stuff, it's just that everyone is competing for my attention and I only have so many hours to spare.Overall it's a good thing, I think we will see the big studios loose footing in the gaming market even more, with the whole Microsoft restructuring blood bath we can already see it, big studios and brands still have their exclusives for now but I imagine they will lose market share overall since there's just so much exceptional stuff being produced by indies, and a good indie game can be just as much fun as the most expensive AAA title.
• dang
  Related:Ideas aren't getting harder to find - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46283129 - Dec 2025 (64 comments)Ideas aren’t getting harder to find - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35743129 - April 2023 (3 comments)Ideas aren’t getting harder to find and anyone who tells you so is a coward - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31485972 - May 2022 (2 comments)
• yalogin
  It’s not that ideas are exhausted but there is a lot of development and we are building layers on top of layers. So one needs to be familiar with them and fully familiar with the outer most layer to generate new ideas, because new ideas utilize and extend this outer most layer.
• rpq
  I wonder about our innate desire to want glory :/
• socktan410
  Perhaps our modern culture might produce less geniuses compared to previous eras, too much focus on "intelligence" as a metric and optimization of existing pathways, decline of reading, etc. ?
• sukhavati
  I think the issue with slowing discovery comes partially if not largely due to the decay in aristocratic pursuits of disinterested knowledge, plus the decay in human capital over the last 150-200 years
• anon
  undefined
• evrimoztamur
  The Ruliad is infinite
• luxuryballs
  If the general public tends to believe there's not much left to discover then I wonder if this sentiment itself might be a clue that the opposite is true to a greater extent, or even that we're arguably "behind" in the short term.
• Menu

  Razengan
  Maybe we're about to enter an Economy of Ideas: with everyone and their grandma soon being able to make anything they can think of, it'll come down to who has the better idea (and the vision to polish and continue it)..The Idea Guys™ will finally get their day :)
• gafferongames
  This is absolutely not true!
• atlgator
  They're just hard for me to find.
• mmmpetrichor
  I would go further and say they're a sniveling slimy worm, unworthy of anyone's love or affection. This holds true for anyone who disagrees with any of my opinions.
• anon
  undefined
• Menu

  tokai
  Ideas are not found. But its a good way to show the readers not to waste time with this essay.
• anon
  undefined
• iwontberude
  [dead]