HN

Comments (59)

• Menu

  cmontella
  I remember Steve from my days working on Eve, he was part of that community and always a big proponent of end-user programming. I was happy to see him working on this project but am not surprised it's shutting down.Nothing to to do with the quality of Val Town, but making a business in this space is really, really hard. You can't start the business without raising millions (Eve raised $2M, Darklang raised $3.5M, Val Town raised $7M), but it's hard to scale out a proof of concept in the time investors want to start seeing an ROI. It seems to me about 2-3 years is all you get for seed runway, when realistically projects like this should take at minimum 5 years incubating. Darklang extended their runway to ~7-8 years by firing all the devs and keeping just the founder on life support. Ultimately even that wasn't enough.But maybe with AI this could work, I dunno.What's required to make it all work is a fundamental leap in programming interface design, but the business side doesn't look any different from a typical SaaS. So unless you hit the ball out of the park you're entering the market with an experimental product, then you have to deal with product-market fit even if you have the right product, so you really only have one shot.It's very hard to go back to investors and ask for another round of funding when there's no discernable market and the product isn't gaining the traction investors would like to see.Anyway, kudos to Steve for fighting the good fight! What would really be great is to read an in-depth post mortem on the project. Looking forward to it if you have time!
• jrmann100
  Not mentioned directly in the blog post, but Val Town was fundamentally organized around the Deno runtime, whose team will stop maintaining it next year after joining Cloudflare [0].[0] https://deno.com/blog/cloudflare
• Menu

  yakkomajuri
  This is sad. We're in a similar space as Val Town (which technically made us competitors) but I've always appreciated the care they had for the craft and the values they drove forward as a company like their transparency (even their investor updates were public).Steve and Tom also individually have some of the best blogs out on the web.I wish them all the best with whatever comes next. I'm pretty sure they'll all do great things.
• Menu

  Zambyte
  It seems like everyone here knows what this is but me. I went to their homepage and I still can't tell what this is. How is this different from just giving your agent access to one of the many hosting services CLIs / MCPs? Did they just pioneer that?
• simonw
  I'm really sad about this. Val Town is a beautiful collection of ideas, but I get how building a sustainable business on top of those ideas (not-quite commodity hosting, since people need to commit to the Val way of building) is extremely hard.I'm definitely looking forward to seeing the code in February when they open source it.
• seanw265
  This is sad to see. I know what it's like to shut down a project that you've spent years on. It's really heartbreaking. I feel for Steve and the rest of the team.I fear this is the reality of anything built around Deno after the Cloudflare acquisition. Thankfully agents are capable of handling most of the migration of the apps that everyone has built on top of it.For anyone looking for a new home for their projects, I'm the founder of Easel.sh [0], an app hosting platform. I've been putting together migration guides covering how to move workloads from Val Town onto Easel. It's not a drop-in replacement for everything Val Town offered, but I think we can be a good fit for quite a few use cases.I'm happy to personally help anyone who is looking to migrate.[0]: https://www.easel.sh
• fcjr
  So bummed to hear! Really appreciate y'all opening your doors to us every Saturday for https://sideprojectsaturday.com/, it's consistently been one of my favorite parts of the week. (Shout out to Justin!)
• samwho
  Loved what Steve and the team at Val Town were building from the very start. So sad to see this news.I remember one of the silly little services I built on Val Town getting DDoS’d and knocking Val Town offline for a short time. Steve sent me a handwritten note and a Val Town baseball cap thanking me for helping them improve their defences. Class act.
• tom-in-july
  Goodbye, Val Town...https://juli--01a1c6ce5cec761daadca9a5a6624b49.web.val.run/Ever since you were esm.town, you were a lovely little platform for the fun side of the web.
• Menu

  hardwaregeek
  Feels like there’s an era of devtools companies coming to a close. Astro, Astral, Deno, Bun, Turso, Void Zero all got acquired. I’m guessing there’s either very compelling acquisition offers being floated or the fundraising/revenue environment isn’t as friendly?
• plesiv
  Steve is incredibly thoughtful about the art of programming. He has written a lot of insightful commentary over the years. A highly recommended read.Steve inspired us to build a val.town-like platform Gitlip (https://gitlip.com/) in early 2025. We quietly stopped working on it about a year ago because it was difficult to get paying customers.
• upmostly
  I've spoken to Steve a few times and he gave great advice.I'm sorry to hear this didn't work out for him, but there's no doubt that he'll get the next one (or maybe the one after that).
• dizzard
  This is a bummer. Val.town was an inspiration for my own open source work on personal apps platforms.
• Menu

  koolala
  We still badly need a replacement for Glitch.com. There are no free dynamic server hosts anymore.
• alabhyajindal
  Sad to hear this, big fan of val.town since the early days.I've been thinking that the idea of a cloud for personal applications makes less sense as time goes on - because that area of the market will be captured by the harnesses that alloe people to build their toy project in the first place - like how Claude can deploy your websites.
• Menu

  prisonguard
  Steve, I don't know whether you can read this but any chance the code can be made open source. It would greatly help me and others to extend your vision.
• kinlan
  Steve and the team at Val town were amazing. I loved the product and I also loved the team who were incredibly approachable and very community centric.Thank you Steve
• jborichevskiy
  I'm gonna miss it. It was such a solid place for a v0.5 of something where I get hosting, a db, subdomains, logging, and more right off the bat.Thank you for a wonderful service!
• ndom91
  Sad to see this. Val town was a great little platform! Lots of cool ideas
• tinyhouse
  I actually created one simple agent back then on Val Town that checks any new sign ups to my app and then posts to Slack. It was free but I've never created anything else on their platform.I kind of liked their story and wanted to support them. Their UX wasn't great for one (back when I tried it at least). But I think the bigger problem is that the big opportunity for them was that they started early before it was crowded, and if they didn't capture a big market share then, now it's too late and impossible to compete. For agents to be useful you need to integrate them with all your services and data, and if you're already using a trusted provider Like Claude or CloudFlare etc. then it's easy just to stick with their offerings.Thanks for the migration guide!
• Menu

  aanet
  Whaaaat. I thought this was a successful business??Sorry to hear this. Hopefully will be open sourced?
• Menu

  rpmisms
  Aw, I liked Val Town. Any self-hosted alternatives people like?
• hacker_88
  There's need for this type of service, make bun town maybe. Open sourcing might get it somewhere
• dorongrinstein
  sorry it did not work out. To your customers: feel free to check out https://controlplane.com - it handles all your use cases and them some. You can converse with it your agent of choice, and it comes with a UI, CLI, API, Terraform, Pulumi and MCP. It lets you run across any cloud and on-prem with the same interface. it is very cost effective and supports ANY service of any cloud, including over a hundred open source templates like Postgres, CockrochDB, Kafka, Rabbit, Cassandra and much more. I am the ceo of Control Plane. Ask me anything. https://controlplane.com
• Menu

  asdev
  Seeing a lot of wind down posts recently, guessing that will only accelerate
• nullstyle
  I’ll say the same thing I did with Deno’s death: it’s a shame.
• crawshaw
  You are great Steve, thanks for building val.town.
• jryio
  Tough
• Menu

  FLeXMurphy
  Not to be a downer but these things built on platforms like Deno seem more like side projects than actual serious ventures. Use at your own risk, I suppose.
• guhcostan
  [flagged]
• sweeppilot
  [flagged]
• KallowayThayer
  [flagged]