Need help?
<- Back

Comments (43)

  • raincole
    > Your agent will pick the hackable one> This changes how people buy hardware. Ask your agent which TV, router, or synth to get, and it will lean toward the one it can change, because that’s the one it can fix later. The buyer never has to think about openness for it to matter.It's just sci-fi and has nothing to do how the current LLMs work.
  • msdrigg
    > Ask your agent which TV, router, or synth to get, and it will lean toward the one it can change, because that’s the one it can fix later.I have not found this to be true. I like the rest of the article and the principle behind it but the title is not backed up at all
  • rgmerk
    For most consumers, tinkering with their shiny new piece of electronics is the last thing they want to do. They want it to just work out of the box.Apple has understood this since forever.
  • palata
    The interesting thought to me is not (at all) that "my agent may pick the hackable one", but rather that LLMs will make it a lot easier to reverse-engineer stuff and actually own our devices.> Then M-Vave did something uncommon for a hardware company. In October it published its own firmware as open source under GPLv3They did it after the alternative firmwares were out of their control. What I take from that is that there is a big need to reverse engineer firmwares, because by defaults companies really don't want to open source them.Ironic how the company released it as GPLv3. Like "we really wanted to keep it proprietary, but now that we feel like we should open source it, we really wouldn't want for a competitor to change it and keep their changes proprietary".
  • danvoell
    "Your Agent Will Pick the Hackable One" - I pick the hackable one. Who wants black box hardware? Every "smart" commercial closed box machine seems to be trying to extract as much out of its users as legally/morally/economically possible. i.e. Right to Repair
  • crazygringo
    > Most buyers won’t care about [replaceable firmware]. Their AI agents will, and more buying decisions are going to run through agents.Citation needed.AI agents don't have any goals of their own. They don't care about anything at all.So when you ask an LLM to recommend a product, it's taking the things your prompt says are important to you, and combining them with professional reviews and user reviews it finds.If you don't say that hackability is important to you, and professional reviews and user reviews aren't bringing that up much either, then the LLM is going to totally ignore hackability.So this post seems to be more about the author's personal wish, rather than based on how actual LLM's work.
  • UqWBcuFx6NV4r
    This is a bizarre work of AI-generated fiction and I have no idea how it hasn’t been buried.
  • footoverhand
    I the consumer would pick the modifiable one, and use agents to modify the closed ones, if needed.
  • micromacrofoot
    It won't for long, they're going to ratfuck the hell out of these models once they need to collect the advertising dollars... just like everything on the web that has come before it. Enjoy it while it lasts.
  • georgemcbay
    I wish for the vision of the future this article posits, and I'm sure it will be true for some limited classes of devices, but a lot of devices rely on the razor blade model and/or advertisements, and those devices are likely to become increasingly securely locked down, not more open.The "agents" don't care which side they are used on and will be just as happy to make security robust for the devices whose creators don't want people changing them as they are attempting to hack into such devices.
  • Philip-J-Fry
    >This changes how people buy hardware. Ask your agent which TV, router, or synth to get, and it will lean toward the one it can change, because that’s the one it can fix later. The buyer never has to think about openness for it to matter.No, it'll suggest which ever manufacturer has paid OpenAI or Anthropic for advertising
  • internet2000
    This is pretty disconnected from reality.> Geoff Stearns is a Product Manager at Google building AI agents and skills.Ah, well, nevertheless.
  • drnick1
    > Ask your agent which TV, router, or synth to get, and it will lean toward the one it can change, because that’s the one it can fix later.What is that hackable TV that your agent found?
  • ale42
    Sounds a bit too idealistic unfortunately. Kudos to M-Wave for open sourcing the firmware of the device, but this is not going to happen anytime soon with [insert random TV or printer brand/model]. There are too many $$$ involved with companies who rely on people running their crappy closed firmwares.
  • agluszak
    > I replaced the home screen on our Google TV, which runs Android, with a custom launcher built for our family, with no ads and no tracking.> Geoff Stearns is a Product Manager at GoogleIronic.
  • techpression
    More likely it will pick 1. The one who has ads for it, 2. The one most recommended in web search results. I’m not really optimistic of this part of the LLM future.
  • logicallee
    would you buy a bluetooth speaker that didn't come with firmware at all, and you can just prompt your AI to write it? Like:"This is a (SOC device model) without any firmware, a (device model) USB speaker is attached to it internally. Write some firmware for it to get it working."And you just have your AI write whatever firmware it wants.Or would you want the company to put a little more effort into it before shipping it? (For example, actually testing it to see if it works at all.)
  • calvinmorrison
    THE HACKABLE WHAT????? I scream into the darkness as I flag and move on
  • ftchd
    [flagged]