<- Back
Comments (195)
- jnwatsonGiven the Hacker News bias towards tech, it is easy to focus on just the challenges of exploiting AI for software development.The problem is, to justify the substantial investment in data centers and the eye-watering valuations of Anthropic and OpenAI, AI has to successfully reach into essentially every niche of the economy. It can't just be a tool to code faster. It must make most jobs faster period. From daycare to farming, we need relatively short-term ways of integrating this technology.AI will survive the hype cycle, but the AI companies very well may end up like railroad companies or Iridium, where the shareholders got zeroed out and then someone comes in, buys the assets for 10 cents on the dollar, and builds something useful out of it.
- tyleoThe tools are good and even getting better but the gap is real. If the tools made people 2x faster AI CEOs would say 5x faster, if they made people 5x faster they’d say 10x faster.I feel like expectations of a gap should be built in.
- SecretDreamsThe tools are good, but the ideas are not. These tools basically see many people building the same things independently, rapidly, and over and over again.I'm not seeing a lot of unique applications. I am seeing some optimization, plenty of rehashing the same crap. Lots of thought outsourcing.Honestly, I'm mixed as someone who also uses these tools. Is it really efficient for 100s of people to be spending tokens and electricity to all make, effectively, the same bad app from their shower thought/idea? I love that we've democratized coding so that it's more accessible to laypeople - but it is mostly all slop and lack of creativity being produced. And, in the rare instances where someone genuinely makes something good, 100x people will then spin their own AI to rip off the same idea.Where does this all go at the end of the day for humanity when nothing is new or creative and we are going backwards in critical thinking along the journey? Especially since the journey IS the thing for humanity - not the end product of the journey.
- josefritzishere[dead]
- rdevilla[dead]
- originiThe industry is just busy overall with day to day work and it just takes ages to implement things.Which also means that it is slow in adoption not because the quality is not here but because you need to do things first.You need an env to run an agent, you need connectors, you need to get that stuff through security etc.The only question is timeline not investment or bubble because AI as is will not go away anymore.I asked before for headcounts or consultants and today I can just use AI for it. Its not the AI which is the problem, its the stuff i mentioned above. We will probably still need a few month in my team alone to close the loop.And whlie we close the loop, models are continesly getting better.
- jrfloChina seems to always have viewed AI as "normal technology". Maybe they know that they're falling behind and won't hit RSI like Anthropic thinks they will, or don't think that it's possible at all. Also notable that Baidu/Xiaomi don't have any frontier models, so it's a bit like Samsung commenting on the AI race
- slowinThe problem isn’t AI, it’s capitalism. I use AI constantly and have built my own personal universe of software. Instead of buying a solution, I build it myself. Instead of using open source, I build exactly what I need and nothing else. Instead of using a library and introducing a dependency, I just use AI to build it in my own code base.This has been revolutionary and game changing for me, but what it’s not is profitable in any way. In fact, quite the opposite. I also don’t even bother open sourcing or distributing what I build. It’s my computing dream, but it is just for me. Capitalism nor our idea of open source fit this model.
- nameless912This all comes down to execs looking for a reason to be relevant. Just like every single "revolution" in software development, the executive set thinks that this is going to be the innovation that allows them to finally hire fewer programmers and deliver better software than ever before, and it's never been true, and won't be true this time.AI has become an incredibly useful tool for competent engineers to build more, better software. Is it orders of magnitude more impactful than, say, the widespread introduction of OOP? yeah, probably. Is it still the same kinda thing? Yeah, absolutely. You can do some _incredible_ stuff as a solo developer with a good coding agent and good domain knowledge these days; as we speak I'm working on a complete astrophotography toolkit that can run off an android smartphone, and this is possible mostly because 1) I already knew enough android to reason about the ecosystem and 2) I know enough about astrophotography to reason about the work that needs doing. Domain knowledge is what separates AI slop from good software that happens to be written using AI, and you can't just magick that out of existence, no matter how much the pointy haired's want it gone.I don't think we're particularly close to an AI system that can fully substitute for human taste, and if we stop pretending we can already have "fully autonomous AI employees" and instead see AI as a new paradigm for building software in the hands of professionals, we have a good chance of actually changing the industry. But stupid hype cycles are gonna stupid hype cycle, and it'll probably take a few more MSFT-level crash outs for us to get to a level of sanity around it.
- TheBlightI'll be a believer when the technology allows them to crank out a new GTA every month.
- kstrauserTo me this reads much like “Buick CEO warns of growing gap between electric car hype and returns.”
- yipinwongIt took them 2 years for their people to report the hype? Or did they never follow what's been going on last 2 years? Hype's been there for years!
- anonundefined
- 999900000999It really looks like we’re starting to see the first failures of vibecoding ( vibe dev ops too) in prod.Can’t send emails, fly or check your bank balance. Ohh well.I would love to see 2027 be the return of QA across tech.
- lenerdenatorI mean, yeah. They're deeply connected to the Chinese state and the Chinese state is trying to undermine the American economy, which has stupidly put a lot of its eggs in the AI hyperscaler basket.It makes total sense that they'd warn of this. They're also somewhat right. Not for the right reasons, mind, but they're right.