Need help?
<- Back

Comments (44)

  • mjdiloreto
    This is a beautiful expression, and the author would do well to refine their notion of taste further.Anyone familiar with Dr. John Vervaeke's work will find another notion, relevance realization (RR), fits nicely.The thing I like about RR over "taste" when talking about AI is that it captures what the taste metaphor does not - that there is a missing _relevant_ dimension of consideration from the LLMs output."Hey you got the code working but this 4000 line PR will never be approved." "You spent tokens hardening the API, when this entire project is just a local test that will never hit production". Etc, etc, ad nauseum.Vervaeke reveals why in his lecture series "Awakening from the Meaning Crisis".Fundamentally, RR cannot be achieved through reason alone. Full stop. Vervaeke uses this fact to point out the irrationality of the "rationalist" movement in order to highlight its dangers (which many would agree the effective altruism crowd has thoroughly proven him right about), but the same framing and argument can be used to explain why your AI has bad taste.There is no way to enumerate the set of dimensions that are or are not relevant in a given real world context. The detail of the universe, combined with the set of actions an agent does (and does NOT!) take leads to a combinatorial explosion of complexity.AI agents need to be told what to do, and even then, they will only stochastically sample what you tell them.Anthropic tells Claude lots of things about Rust, for example, and things to look out for in security context, but they fundamentally cannot put enough information in to grant the agent the ability to wisely choose what is and is not relevant. You can only ever consider _some_ relevant things.I don't personally think it is impossible for computers to perform RR, it's just that today's agents do not, which is why its taste and yours differ.
  • abahlo
    Love the style, hate the scrolljacking
  • epgui
    This is awful to read, and I really wanted to read it, but I gave up anyway. I’m on my iPhone.
  • aDyslecticCrow
    The way the website over-animates my scrolling, to the point of going multiple seconds behind the input; I just ended up scrolling a bunch, and watching the website as a silent video.A video would have been been simpler and easier to navigate. A video would have been faster as well; even when scrolling ahead i would have liked a 150% option.
  • Luke2642
    I enjoyed it. If the scrolly art is not your cuppa and want to just read the MD file version it's under the index button at the very bottom right.
  • decidu0us9034
    I think if you're asking what humans "bring to the table" you've already lapsed into misantrhopy. I don't want to live in a world where my art is evaluated by non-humans, I want a separate internet where it's not even visible to them.
  • jrdnfrd
    It's not true that LLMs can only perform as well as the average of their training data. They can learn to perform at an elite level in domains like programming by extracting quality signals from code reviews, bug fixes, tutorials, etc, and the labs are doing post-training to teach them what excellent code looks like.Maybe right now that's only true in a few domains like math, programming, language translation, maybe some writing task? But soon it will be true in many more domains.Given that we can't hope to out-execute the LLMs on the things they are elite at, what is left for us? This site wants to reserve "taste" for the humans, but I'm not sure LLMs won't learn "taste" too.The best I've got right now is that humans live and interact with the real world in ways that disembodied LLMs can't (yet). Maybe they will be the theoreticians and we the experimentalists?
  • achairapart
    I don’t know, humans.txt[0] was a thing well before this and LLMs.[0]: https://humanstxt.org
  • xydac
    love the concept - just make it a video instead !!!
  • FrameworkFred
    I both really enjoyed this and couldn't finish it
  • tiborsaas
    Was this shadowbanned? Found it on the frontpage, now it's gone.
  • xnx
    Good guidelines for creative work (I assumed the author made movies). Not great principles for user interface (outside of video games).
  • gregrobson
    Love it! I actually like the scrolljacking as it forces you to take your time and actually take in the sentiment. So easy to skim everything we read on the web.
  • a3w
    I am human. But not american, so perhaps that is why I don't even understand some of the concepts.
  • fg137
    I was looking for a simple page with a correctly rendered md file. But what an eyesore this is.
  • hamuraijack
    The irony of this page is that it's clearly written with AI.
  • vunderba
    The 2022's called - they want their hands back.https://imgur.com/a/3YuSVrDSeriously - these are so bad I almost want to believe this was done using Stable Diffusion 1.5 on purpose. Or maybe they used a Simpson LoRA.
  • happyopossum
    Sorry - can't dedicate that much time to simply read a few dozen words of text. The irony is thick here - as a .md it purports to be a plain text file but nooooo, it's ~50MB of janky, slow, unskippable animations which each reveal 3-5 words at a time.
  • dsjoerg
    Ironically, I'm a human, tried for five seconds to get something of value, and then bolted. Who is this for?
  • smusamashah
    This is ironic. human-md.ai an AI generated website.
  • MetaMalone
    This seems cool but like can I just have the blog post. Very annoying to scroll on mobile
  • SwellJoe
    The prose reads a lot like AI wrote it. But, it may just be in the slide deck marketing website style that AI has so much of in their training data.It's also a high bullshit design...a lot of random shit happening for no reason other than to make it hard to read and weird to navigate.Maybe good intentions, but I can't get past the surface level stuff that's very off-putting.
  • 0x4e
    Beautiful, well said, human.
  • gcanyon
    > A reminder, in plain text, of what I think.That page is anything but plain text...
  • what
    For those that just want to read it without the cutesie animation as you scroll, open the menu and the last item lets you read the md file.
  • meshweaver
    Frankly, I give up reading a piece as soon as I recognize that tired, punchy marketing-speak. Looks visually appealing though. Might be cooler if scrolling completely controlled the animation playback. Scrolling is currently a nuisance.
  • redanddead
    Why not Humans.md? why are our agentic systems defaulting to one human its dumb
  • etherlink
    [dead]
  • frank_debug
    [dead]