Need help?
<- Back

Comments (149)

  • smurf9852
    I would like to take it one step further:You are not your body.This is the ultimate teaching of the Buddha.You are not your body, you are not your mind, you are not your thoughts.You are not them, because you can't control them. If you were in control, you wouldn't have pain or anxiety or craving, because you would simply choose to not have pain or anxiety or craving. No sane man would choose to have pain or anxiety or craving. Yet you have pain and anxiety and craving, because you are not in control of them, because they are not You.Cravings, anger, thoughts - they come up, they exist. Just like a dream exists while sleeping. But, they are not You, just like a dream is not you.The true You, is only awareness of being. It is a calm, ever present place beyond all physical sensations. It can be accessed at any moment. For most of us, this takes practice in the form of meditation, as our ego resists.About craving and your book, it works because shows you a separation of craving and you. Allowing you to be aware of craving without having to act upon it. Because you learn it is not the true You.This idea can be of help, besides the regular therapy or book, to free yourself of suffering.If you would like to know more, I can recommend the teaching of the Buddha or Ramana Maharshi:https://johndavidsatsang.international/illusion-and-the-body...
  • alexpotato
    This is largely in line with Tim Galwey's "Inner Game" books [0] specifically and Zen in general.After reading many of Gallwey's books and also Zen and the Art of Archery [1], I would summarize it all down into one sentence:Western coaching focuses on telling your body what to do, Zen coaching focuses on observing what your body is doing.e.g. this story from the Inner Game of Skiing [2] summarizes it well:"I didn't tell people how to stand, shift their weight etc. I just told them:- observe the angle of your skis to the ground- flat on the ground is 1- as far over as you can tilt is 10- just feel what angle you are at as your are moving down the hill.A young lady then came up to ask me 'So what is the correct angle??'. I told her 'There is no correct angle, just observe what angle your skis are.' "If you prefer a video example, this youtube video of Gallwey teaching people hit play tennis for the first time is great [3] (note: it's very low video quality but excellent at showing his techniques).0 - Gallwey's books: https://link.amazon/B00K1eqwt1 - Zen and the Art of Archery https://link.amazon/B0326PLb72 - Inner Game of skiing https://link.amazon/B0igf0GrK3 - Gallway teaching tennis https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ieb1lmm9xHk
  • Jonovono
    Hmm, I wouldn't really say that's the takeaway of "Easy way to quit smoking" that really resonates with smokers. In fact, i'd say it's the opposite message the book lays out.This article is suggesting you have to "battle" your cravings, to stop smoking.The books message is the opposite. It's seeing that you gain nothing from cigarettes, that they have created the solution to a problem they themselves created. It's seeing that there is nothing to "give up". There is no battling your cravings.In fact, you have already lost if you are battling your cravings, because you are giving power to that thing. You are affirming that you are having to "give up" something by battling through the cravings, surely there must be some value in that thing because it's so hard to give it up.No, there isn't. There is no battle.
  • dackle
    I read Allan Carr's The Easy Way To Stop Smoking in 1999. I read it in one sitting while smoking a pack of cigarettes, and when I finished the book I never smoked again.It has been 27 years, so I don't remember the details of the book and may be getting it wrong, but my takeaway was that the book circumvented all of the excuses your brain comes up with to start smoking again. It's like a nicotine craving sends a message to your brain, which comes up with an excuse to allow you to smoke again. For example, about four hours into "quitting smoking", your brain starts coming up with stuff like: "I'll just cut down to 6 a day", or "Maybe today isn't the best day to quit", or "I'll just smoke on weekends", or "I'll start smoking menthols", or "I'll just have one now and see if I can make it through the rest of the day", and then you're right back where you started. The book had an answer for all of these off-ramps, and made it clear that they were all created by nicotine cravings.
  • matthewpick
    This reminds me a lot of DNRS and Primal Trust, tools that are supposed to help with the mental shift in healing from Long Covid and other chronic illnesses.
  • sph
    While I agree with most of the article, I gotta add that Allen Carr’s method is not fool-proof.The first read through is magical in its obviousness and simplicity. It works for a lot of people, which will praise it as if magic. But if by any chance you fall into the trap of smoking again, the book will have lost 90% of its power, simply because you have seen your cravings overcome its message once.It’s taken me 10 more years after first reading the book, using the conventional techniques of nicotine substitutes, to finally quit for good.
  • geye1234
    Yes, the technique for dealing with anxiety described here is pretty much identical:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lGa-jQJazpYThis stuff should really be taught in schools.Acts form habits, whether for good or for bad. The mind and the body are one substance, two aspects of the same thing.
  • jakeinspace
    Quitting sugar is a funny example, because for many people, some of those craving feelings might be coming from the gut microbiome demanding more of what it wants. I had to cut out most sugars/simple carbs for gut health reasons and what do you know, the cravings vanished simultaneously with the other unpleasant symptoms.Not saying that's the only driver for sugar cravings of course, the brain and gut are in dialogue.
  • nuancebydefault
    It is indeed not willpower that steers the body most. The more the reasoning brain imposes will on the body, the more the body/unconscious protests by causing pain.The art is instead to assure the body that all is fine, for example calming it by rithmic movements like walking or boxed breathing. After a while the body admits there's nothing it needs to fight for, the pain and cravings deminish.
  • FrankyHollywood
    "you want to smoke because the craving feels bad, not because you actually want the cigarette."This is an interesting assumption I often think about. The cigarette makes you feel different, or even better. Alcohol can do the same, it brings your mind in another state.I'm not saying you should smoke or drink away your stress and anxieties but using a substance can be a positive experience, just like taking a run or have a fun night at a comedy club.Should one only strive for positive experiences from natural effects, and if so, can I play GTA6 to feel better?
  • baud9600
    It occurs to me that if craving can be addressed one-battle-at-a-time, the opposite may be true: procrastination (or resistance to positive change) can be addressed one tiny bite at a time? I’m not sure what that looks like but it seems like an inversion of the same idea? I’d like to know more about this.Great comments on this thread, thanks all.
  • iandanforth
    The analogy that works for me is as follows:1. Noticing and namingThere is a mental phenomenon, like tension, or craving, or distraction. It may not be obvious. The obvious name might be "back pain", or "cigarettes", or "stress". You first learn to notice and name a truer, primary cause. This is why it can work so fast. Sometimes, all you need to learn is that there is a truer primary cause for it to become obvious.2. Shifting focus to an incompatible mental state.The knowledge that pain is caused by tension is incompatible with a focus on injury. The mental representation of one negates the other. The focus on a neutral process of craving negates the belief about physical need. The knowledge of the process of distraction inhibits the focus on stressful distractors.In the brain you're finding activations which inhibit the firing of undesirable neural activity. The exact mental state will vary by individual, which is why particular visualizations work so well for some and not others.3. PracticeThrough repeated practice of associating stimuli/experience with the truer more desirable mental state you learn the habit of going straight from the stimulus to the good state, bypassing the undesirable state. You inhibit the brains old prediction of the next link in the chain and replace it with a prediction of a better one.Now the above works very well when there is a truer root cause than the one you've noticed in the past, but the crazy thing is that it works even if you can only convince yourself its a truer root cause. Even if your body really is damaged and is reporting as much with pain you can use the above (or similar meditation techniques) to master/overcome/ignore that pain, though it is harder and requires much more of the practice step.
  • leobg
    Made me think of this anecdote from Harry Browne's book How I Found Freedom in an Unfree World:> One night I had to give a lecture and she announced that she was going out with someone else. I was sure they’d wind up in bed — and it infuriated me. I didn’t want to stop her but I still felt terribly jealous. On the way to the lecture, I stopped for dinner. For the previous three hours, I’d been unable to think of anything but the terrible thing I was sure was going to happen. I finally decided that I wouldn’t be able to give the lecture unless I calmed down.> After ordering my dinner, I started to use the technique. I had never seen the other man involved — which always seems to make such a person more formidable. So I pictured him as the exact opposite of me, the kind of man I wouldn’t like, the kind of man who could sweet-talk women away from their lovers. I imagined them doing together every obscene thing I could think of. 21 I was determined to keep thinking about the scene over and over again until it no longer bothered me emotionally. However, I suddenly realized that I was thinking about the lecture I was going to give; I hadn’t made it all the way through the imaginary sex scene even once. So I turned my mind back to the horrible scene and concentrated on it again.> But it quickly became apparent that my mind had wandered once again. And then it dawned on me that the scene no longer held any terror for me — not even any interest, in fact.> So I spent the rest of my dinner time planning my lecture and never gave the jealousy problem another thought. In all, it had taken only about five minutes of attention to eliminate all the pain and fear.
  • jwpapi
    There are two wolfs in you: The one that does wants what you should do and the one that wants what you crave. Which one is growing? The one you feed.
  • microsoftedging
    Interesting FT article about the usage of this method in person with a group of smokers:"I have smoked about 250,000 cigarettes. This is how I quit" https://www.ft.com/content/8bc82ad7-625e-44a6-b582-4ffdfee72...
  • mdmower
    If I'm interested in reading more about this without picking up books specific to smoking, tennis, and spiritually, is "The Experience Machine" by Andy Clark in the same vein?
  • dansf
    Wow, this is so interesting. My girlfriend and I just finished reading Allen Carr, which has helped a lot with anxiety. And the reason why I picked it up was because I thought anxiety might be amplifying or even causing physical pain. The fact that other people were able to overcome pain through mental motions gives me a lot of hope. Thanks for linking this.
  • gcanyon
    This reminds me of the centipede's dilemma: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Centipede%27s_DilemmaBasically, you ask the centipede how he walks, he reflects on it, and loses the ability.
  • Michael_Frost
    It all sounds great but physical cravings can be deeply ingrained in your neuronal structure and can take a long time to get rid of. I wonder to what extent this is one of those things where once you do this it feels like a massive breakthrough, but then 2 months later you're back to where you started as if nothing happened.More on this: https://chrislakin.blog/p/flaky-breakthroughs
  • dzink
  • ahofmann
    I really like what the author wrote and I'm one of those people who was freed from their chronic back pains by just reading the first 60 pages of jon Sarnos book.
  • dalemhurley
    There are certainly a lot of truth in cure your body by mind but there are significant dangers in going too far. As a runner too often I push through the mental wall, sometimes it leads to far worse injuries. Same as a founder, I pushed through many times and the end results were not worth the cost. Balance is the key that I am yet to discover.
  • gweinberg
    I would assume someone who said he was cured just by reading the reviews was joking.
  • shermantanktop
    For me, what I think of as ”you“ is not a tiny homunculus in my head which steers the rest of me with commands and controls. “You“ are not in control, “you” is a crowd of competing impulses and memories, with a thin mask on it that lets you imagine yourself as the boss.
  • saturnd
    Great article I first heard about Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind through Steve Jobs. Just finished reading it and gained so much from it. Even though I struggle to meditate every single day, I truly believe sticking with it will pay off immensely.
  • zombocomvibes
    Good article and worth internalizing before a crisis occurs.Mind over matter is a futile battle. Your body and all of its autonomous systems can't be neglected. Learn to work together or suffer the consequences.
  • iotage
    Over 20 years ago I quit smoking after being a pack and a half smoker since high school. I didn’t torture myself by trying to quit, by cutting down or using some aid like nicotine alternatives.Instead, I simply ran through a simple mental exercise every time I started a cigarette. I imagined and felt the few things that I really didn’t like about smoking - the look and smell of an old full ashtray, the taste of a stale cigarette, the gagging feeling of a first daily cigarette one sometimes experiences, the feeling of smoke in my eyes etc. Every cigarette every time, and after that I would just carry on with my cigarette. I didn’t try to give up smoking.After a few weeks I realized I was often stubbing out the cigarettes early, not through a conscience decision! A few weeks later I just … stopped wanting a cigarette, and haven’t wanted one since.Today, for the first time I hear of Allen Carr’s technique. It’s not the same, but related and I’m amazed I never heard of it! Both it seems result in changing one’s core beliefs?One note of warning: I think this technique could be really dangerous if applied to things like overeating etc.Another important point I think is that I was in an environment conducive to stopping smoking - my wife hated it. If your in an environment where smoking is rewarded, like for example smoking with a buddy, or regular pub sessions, it surely would be less effective.If anyone wants more info or advice on this, email me.
  • blobbers
    I would guess cravings get worse for awhile, then slowly better. I think most people get stumped on the part where the cravings get worse.
  • delichon
    > The same thing happens with John Sarno’s book, Healing Back Pain: The Mind-Body Connection.This was me, flat on my back, pretty much paralyzed in bed from pain from moving in any direction. I bought the book on my tablet and started reading, got to the part about how I was doing it exactly wrong, and that getting up and moving is the way out. That was a starter's pistol for me. I hobbled my way out of back pain and that has been my first resort ever since.I ignored the woo woo about subconscious self sabotage.
  • jrrc_dev
    I've been learning about reoccurring pain, lethargy or illness in the body and that these symptoms can occur in response to trauma (often repressed)- its a sign that emotions are stuck and need to be allowed/worked through.
  • astral_drama
    Nice techniques. And you can also let go of steering altogether. Here's an apt fight club scene for the compulsive self optimizing, self improving control freaks out there.https://youtu.be/38FMDG7tiA4?is=2d-Vd9CWJIHsJzWK
  • blueblazin
    Dale Carnegie's book How to Stop Worrying and Start Living is full of such anecdotes.
  • SillyUsername
    Sounds like mindfulness which formalised this practice. Maybe I've misunderstood it?
  • hhahahahahah
    stare at bellybutton stare some more keeping staringyou have reached nirvana
  • riceflippa
    There are MANY eastern things(not just philosophies) like patanjali yogasutras that is the framework for this, & is basically are cures for a great life, but the west(by western medical propaganda - which is big pharma + western inferiority complex) will only come to it if it is presented in a western way
  • snvzz
    Try this with time: Every time you feel the need to check what time it is, make a quick guess before looking at the clock.
  • hhahahahahah
    yeah rightand we all find nirvana...
  • vatsachak
    This is such bullshit. Pain is a physical signal from your body telling you that a part of you is compromised.I believe that you can train yourself to ignore pain, but that's literally a last resort. And my experience with this was that the pain just manifests in other ways, like anxiety.Call me ancient but I think that the reverse is true, it's easier to eliminate mental anguish through bodily improvement than the converse
  • dartharva
    I guess this is why even crippling social anxiety tends to dissipate in cases where the activity being engaged is thoroughly more interesting
  • PunchTornado
    This blog post cured my back pain
  • anon
    undefined
  • x______________
    ...to quit smoking
  • themgt
    Often in life, your body is the one steering you. And sometimes, to get to do the thing you want, you can’t just convince yourself with reason or arguments, or will yourself, or do the exercises to get there - you need to learn the magic formula, the secret words, to trick the body into acting in a way that gets you the outcome you want.Sometimes we need to find a way to steer the body, and the body only listens when you say the magic words. I like these examples, not only because they are all actually powerful and useful, but also because it feels like I am whispering the secrets of the universe - that through saying the magic words, I am being granted special root access to my own programming.Modern humans reinventing the bicameral mind from first principles. This is a golden retriever's inner monologue seeing a treat being held out and hearing "sit"