<- Back
Comments (92)
- thewanderer1983To quote the article “We have a government that ‘gets it,’” Deegan said. “They see what Big Tech monopolists have done to local news.For those who haven't been alive longer than social media. Local media was destroyed by large traditional media conglomerates that bought up all of the them during the golden era of traditional media. Now that they aren't profitable and are being kept alive by government how will this solve those problems?
- abathologistThis is excellent news (unless you are a stooge of, or advocate for, democratic erosion) because> Correlations and cluster analyses show that high levels of secure funding for public media systems and strong structural protections for the political and economic independence of those systems are consistently and positively correlated with healthy democracies. ("Funding Democracy: Public Media and Democratic Health in 33 Countries", https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/19401612211060255)
- MenethCanadian journalists now have a financial incentive to not critizise the government too much, lest the funding be retracted.
- ghastmasterDoes Canada have strict regulations on employee salaries? If not, employers of journalists would be inclined to pay less over time. In a "free market", the net wages are what matters to accepting a position for the employee.Likewise, if an independent journalist see net income at a comparable rate to other industries and the bills are paid, in a competitive market they will lower the price of their output to compete.
- aborsyCanadian residents will pay for it substantially via never ending taxes across ever growing facets of life. Big governments will always over spend and accumulate dept.There is no easy solution. The best is to leave it up to people to choose their sources.Unfortunately, Canada is moving in wrong directions. Canadians haven't lived in EU to understand where the policies of their government (pivot to Europe and European model, if it's real) is leading to.
- offtotheracesCan someone explain why government-funded media is a positive? Some things to consider:1. What if the government was right-wing and the news produced reflected that - would you still support it? 2. Investigative journalism was birthed in the free market era of yellow journalism, funded by consumers buying newspapers and being served ads - where is this supposed golden age of government funded media that people refer to? 3. For every Fox News, there’s a CNN/MSNBC/. For every WSJ, there’s a WaPo/NYT/LAT/etc. Aka privately funded media results in heavy left wing skew - what’s the gap that government funded media fills? 4. Government funded media is by definition propaganda - that doesn’t concern you? 5. Of the government is paying journalists’ salaries, how does that reduce conflict of interest in holding higher ups accountable more so than for journalists and privately funded outlets? Wouldn’t both be hesitant to go after their respective bosses?
- uptrailsI think the snarky comments about "state owned media" miss the point.We shouldn't pretend that there's no political risk, no matter if it's structured as a tax break or direct ownership: every time you tie the well-being of journalists to government policy, you inject some bias into the process.However, journalism as such is not financially sustainable in the era of internet clickbait and AI slop, so you kinda need to subsidize reporting if you want to have any reporting at all. Otherwise, all the local news you're gonna get are gonna be Facebook gossip, fake stories engineered for clicks, and paid PR pieces.Like, yeah, BBC minces their words when it comes to criticizing government policy, but they can also afford to send real journalists to cover real news. Do you not want that?
- dprobeGood. Public funding of media, public funding of election campaigns and public funding of healthcare… it’s not perfect, but it helps, if the goal is to have a healthy society. Imagine a USA without FoxNews, superPACs and refused patients because of money.
- urbsgpwWe have public TV and radio in Slovenia and while I would not call for defunding it, it is an incredibly biased institution and I can't buy that any human institution would be otherwise - we all have a worldview and birds of feather flock together. So while they do keep a more civil level of discourse, they are also incredibly smug and have a superiority complex even though it's not like the journalists they have on the payroll are the brightest tools in the shed. Another issue is that, like every institution that doesn't have to fight to survive, they are incredibly cavalier when it comes to their work ethic and costs. The latter doesn't bother me as much because you can potentially get some brilliant stuff done if everybody leaves you alone (Adam Curtis documentaries on the BBC), the obvious left wing bias, however, is problematic.
- asdfasdfasdf222Despite what the article says, funding of journalists is controversial. Im a little disappointed that the article reads like a press release. The controversy comes from the fact that this is not a tax write off open to everyone. You have to be approved by a council that is ultimately appointed by the government. The money comes from big tech aggregators. The second point in the article is that it is not open to companies whose ownership is not separate from news. This means small community outlets are out. It’s really a subsidy to large news corporations. They are afraid of social media and other sources of news people are turning to. It’s potentially about many things but ideological diversity is not one of them.
- BurningFrogSo who counts as a proper "news organization" and/or "journalist" in this scheme?
- JdeBPJust to reiterate, for the Hacker News commentators sagely predicting in the future tense what vaguely bad things will happen to Canada as a result of a programme that has been running since 2019: It's even in the headline that this is a commitment to keeping going with something that has been happening for years and started out as a 5 year experiement, 7 years ago. You can actually observe what has happened during this time, and patently the most excessive doom-mongering has not come true, when it has had ample chance to.And yes, you can read all about how it works, who qualifies, what the details are, who administers the programme, and more besides. There are even 6 years of annual reports.* https://www.canada.ca/en/canadian-heritage/services/funding/...* https://nmc-mic.ca/lji/about-lji/how-it-works/* https://www.canada.ca/en/canadian-heritage/services/funding/...* https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/busines...
- nubinetworkThis sounds great on paper, but the reality is that local news in Canada is dying, if it's not dead already... I wouldn't be surprised if robellus winds up taking most of the money, where it's just a drop in the bucket to them... but big media execs need more ivory back scratchers, amirite?
- walrus01One of the dangers of being an English language speaking country located next to the US, in the era of global media, is that if you don't make intentional political moves to support your local media and journalism, is that it'll get steamrolled by American media due to the disparity in size between the economies. And the sheer inertia and might behind something like a Paramount or Fox.The influence of American media has already been seen extensively in Canada with "maple MAGA" things like the Alberta separatism movement and referendum.
- exabrialI don't want to hear anyone complaining about billionaires lol. You just made a bunch of them. This is how 1%ers are made.
- canadiantimGood. Only the government knows best.
- mmoossWhile not deal-breakers, how do we optimally draw two lines:* What is news? Someone's hot takes on social media? What if a journalist quits the NY Times and starts a solo Substack publication? What if they do the same but post only on Twitter? What if a wealthy indvidual or corporation starts a news org with 10 journalists, otherwise professional, but publishes all brazen disinformation, some dangerous (e.g., dangerous health advice)? What about The Onion?* How do you prevent government interference? You can structure the funding so its distribution is essentially automatic, such as the OP's tax break for journalist salaries. But once journalism orgs are dependent on the funding, the government can change that. In the US I wonder if the First Amendment would prohibit discrimination based on politics.> Meta blocked news on Facebook and Instagram in Canada rather than pay under the Online News Act.Is it a loss to receive less news via social media?
- sick_of_slop[dead]
- metalsiliconYTWow, just the tax credit alone will cost $500 million. Didn't know Canada had money to spare like that.
- skybrianProbably better if it's a variety of funding sources, particularly in the US where sometimes there is a Trump?Maybe for Canada it's ok though.
- k0morebi[flagged]
- userbinator[flagged]