Need help?
<- Back

Comments (180)

  • Animats
    Attempts at governance are futile until we recognize that we have built a machine and set it on its course. Instead, we pretend that the market is a natural phenomenon best left alone, and we fail to hold its mechanism designers to account. We need to tear down and rebuild that machine, reprogramming it so that human flourishing, not corporate profit, becomes its goal.This article has useful insights. It points out that capitalism is an optimization engine for something. Shareholder value and CEO compensation, mostly. It reminds us of something that many people would prefer be forgotten - capitalism operates under rules set by governments, and those shape the market. Tax law matters - what's deductible warps spending patterns. Bankruptcy law matters - who gets left holding the bag? Corporation law matters - how immune are executives from the consequences of their decisions? Labor law matters - do people go to jail for wage and hour law violations?All of those are changeable by legislation. Most have become much more favorable to companies since 1970. That's not necessarily permanent. We had a New Deal in the 1930s, following the Gilded Age of the 1920s and the crash of 1929.
  • michalsustr
    It’s a long article, and the most important idea is buried towards the end:> That’s where I come back to the idea of mechanism design as reverse game theory. Rather than asking ourselves the rules of the game we are now playing, it calls us to ask “What game ought we to be playing?” And that question leads me imperatively to my answer: “The game of human flourishing.”I wholeheartedly agree: we should think way harder about what we want humanity to optimize for collectively, rather than keeping it haphazard.The current economic system is built on the idea of ‘shareholder value maximisation’, which, in a finite world, will ultimately become simply ‘value extraction’. With AI, we’ve built an automated value extractor, which can extract value even faster than was done before. Because of that, the old model can no longer work for improving human flourishing — in a finite world, it will inevitably lead to economic accumulation by few entities, throttling the economic flow.
  • CoolestBeans
    I don't disagree with anything O'Reilly is saying but lets also call out the proximate cause which is that ZIRP era allowed these companies to grow to grotesque proportions and incentivized upstarts to shoot big in green fields rather than compete in known markets. Now interest rates are back and tech companies are cannibalizing their core competencies on the back of AI. Will markets begin slapping wrists for reckless spending and will upstarts see weakness and stab at exposed bellies? No guarantee they will but it is more possible than analysts are realizing.
  • jansport123
    The yuppies who dominated wallstreet in the 80s started streaming to SV. Now we have “VC influencers” - they sit around in a podcast style and talk endless nonsense about the “future” in a very self serving way. I don’t know if SV ever had integrity but these days it seems thinner than ever.
  • smath
    Great article and great discussion here. This is a core topic of our time, up there along with stuff like climate change.Here is an honest Q: does this change in behavior (focus on value extraction) make it harder for people genuinely interested in value creation?
  • Murfalo
    > In my 2005 essay “What Is Web 2.0?” I described how the companies that survived the dotcom bust had all, in one way or another, figured out how to help people navigate the resulting information explosion at scale. As Herbert Simon noted in 1971, an abundance of information leads to a scarcity of attention. In the face of increasing information abundance, he predicted that we would use machines to help us better allocate our time and attention. And so it has transpired: Information has become so abundant that it defies manual curation. Instead, powerful, proprietary algorithmic systems use the data they collect to match users with the answers, news, entertainment, products, applications, and services they seek. Today’s AI is in many ways a continuation of this arc.This is something I've been thinking about a lot. For so long our algorithms have been weaponized against ourselves, but it really feels like we are agonizingly close to finally being able to put them to good use... Couldn't come sooner!
  • 0xcafefood
    > AI is the real deal, a transformative technology like the internet. And its leading company, Anthropic, looks to be turning into an actual business with cash flow and profits. But others, even those like OpenAI with enormous revenues, are still dependent on massive additional capital infusions to survive.Are Anthropic's financials actually that much stronger than OpenAI's? They continue to rely on massive capital infusions to survive too.
  • joewhale
    Greed and lack of purpose.
  • amluto
    > Likewise, Amazon, which used to call itself the most customer-centric company on earth, now puts sixteen ads and four organic results on a typical search results page. Sometimes, it may take scrolling past three screens of results to reach the first organic search result. And by “the first organic search result,” I mean “the best guess of the company’s smartest algorithms for what the user is actually looking for.” In former times, that was the top result. No more.It’s slightly worse. The actual thing the user is looking for is often inserted as a paid ad before the identical organic result.
  • rr808
    Fascinating that one of the reasons SV got started was because land was cheap and climate along with low cost of living attracted engineers. Seems the opposite now its the most expensive part of the world to build a company. Sure the talent is there but its just too costly.
  • musicale
    Bill Gross came up with pay-per-click advertising, and then Google perfected it. And that totally was this new, again, once again, mechanism design, pay-per-click advertising, totally transformative economic mechanism.Tim implies this is great, but...Advertising on the commercial web led to adtech, which "perfected" surveillance capitalism, which is one of the things he is complaining about.Perhaps he felt it was acceptable until "don't be evil" (rather inevitably) started limiting Google's growth (and was therefore abandoned.)
  • caminante
    To me, this is the money quote:>Silicon Valley has gotten addicted to value capture without value creation. Think about it: 75 to 80% of IPOs are for companies without any profits. Add in acquisitions of pre-IPO companies and the numbers are likely even worse. It’s like a horse race where bettors can collect their winnings when the horse has rounded the first or second turn.
  • bix6
    Fantastic read thank you
  • soundworlds
    One point I always see missed: the world wide web was released as an open protocol, and this did not come from Silicon Valley, but CERN in Europe.I'm not saying that Silicon Valley is inherently bad, but the game there has always been venture capital and proprietary productization. And somehow Silicon Valley gets the credit for the Open Internet that we all miss.This is not to shame any one culture, but it is super important that we are accurate about which environments incentivize human-flourishing-tech.
  • smath
    In a way, our current free-market capitalist system solves a distributed optimization problem, using prices as a signal. It is distributed because each unit (person, business) is free to make its own decision. The profit motive is useful as a signal for optimization. But it is not necessary optimal; I believe it is a proxy for something else, namely overall human welfare, and good functioning of society, but since we cannot easily measure or agree on these other things, we use price. Whenever we use a proxy to optimize a different objective, it is possible to 'overfit' [0], i.e. get worse on the real objective. I feel we will see the emergence of other, maybe better, systems, in our lifetime. Its good to see people are thinking along these lines [1][0] https://sohl-dickstein.github.io/2022/11/06/strong-Goodhart....[1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12207456/
  • augment_me
    Great breakdown of the problem, but we get no viable path to a solution, and IMO where are some misguided comparisons.1) When Unix was made the hardware gap between Bell Labs and a uni comp-sci dept was a single minicomputer. Bell Labs was also legally barred from commercializing it due to the 1956 AT&T Antitrust Consent Decree. Today the frontier AI requires gigawatt-scale data centers costing a couple of tens of billions of dollars. No open software protocols or MCP servers can decentralize a market when the underlying compute substrate in itself is an industrial monopoly.2) The author argues that governance fails unless we reprogram the corporate incentive machine, yet he expects AI labs to voluntarily build open ecosystems inside this capitalist market he just proved is inescapable with the shareholder arguments. Even if every lab agrees that displacing consumers ruins the macroeconomy, any lab that sacrifices margins for "human flourishing" will just be out-competed.---Like, he is against government regulations, but at the same time fails to see that Bell Labs would have probably commercialized UNIX if it was not forced to not do so by the antitrust law. So the previous solution is ignored, and the new solution 'reprogram the machine' has no plan or suggestion on how to do it.
  • mrdependable
    This really put into words why these AI companies piss me off so much.
  • jameskilton
    The pursuit of money and power.
  • mentalgear
    Greed, quasi-monopolies, megalomaniacs, fascists: Basically what you get through out history if a society allows for too much power getting concentrated in the hands of a few. And it never ends well for society.
  • paulstovell
    He mentions the book Incorruptible, which the book I got the most value from this year. I am in the midst of removing this corruption from my own company and the results are amazing. Counterintuitively, it’s also a better result for my investors, even though the standard VC company playbook is what causes most of the corruption in the first place.
  • segmondy
    Nothing, it's the same SV. It's just time that has changed.
  • bluegatty
    Yes, supportive of this, but TBC there's at least a healthy degree of value creation going on. Sometimes, even goofy people we 'do not like' are even creating a lot of value.I'm not positive on the Uber makers, and Uber broke a lot of rules - but - even then - Uber is still kind of a good operational innovation.At the very same time Uber was 'bad' for breaking some civic codes, they were 'good' for disrupting very gold and entrenched systems that needed some competition.I don't think it's a 'paradox' it's just the reality of our complicated systems." It’s in the overriding economic incentives of today’s shareholder capitalism. "It's been that way forever.Columbus was more of a Capitalist than explorer. When he got out from under the thumb of 'regulations' he plundered.There were rules against putting people into slavery and all sorts of conventions around serfdom etc. - he 'got outside of that where the rules did not apply' and when those guys starting making $, more powerful interests wanted in on the action. Until we had wars to re-instate social conventions and then some.
  • BrenBarn
    This article suffers from "Hacker News syndrome", viz., the tendency to describe things as problems with tech when they are problems with society as a whole. The rent-seeking, inequality, warped incentives, and "living in different worlds" problems described here pervade the whole economy. They are perhaps most obvious in tech, but they are everywhere.That said, the article lays out the problem pretty well. In particular this:> We need to tear down and rebuild that machine, reprogramming it so that human flourishing, not corporate profit, becomes its goal.. . . acknowledges that improving things requires change that is in some degree "destructive", in that it involves undoing things that have been done and tearing out things that are already in place. This is something that is often missed by "institutionalists" and others of their ilk. We cannot make things better with just more good; we need less harm.> The betting economy, within reason, is a good thing. Speculative bets on the future are how we fund innovation and build infrastructure ahead of the prosperity it will bring.This is maybe barely true, but I think it's much less true than is implied here. Speculative bets are not a good thing. Solid bets are a good thing. It's possible that some degree of speculation is a useful spice to be sprinkled into the economy, but if so it's much, much, less, like maybe 1000 or 100,000 times less, than what we have now.The other issue is that without constant attention to inequality, even a small level of speculation quickly spirals out of control, because those whose speculative bets pay off now have an enormous amount of spare wealth with which to bet even more speculatively. This leads to a distorted economy which is responsive only to the speculations of a tiny class of people who got lucky with their previous bets. (They got lucky. They did not "succeed". They got lucky. This is another problem with how we view it.) This is the situation we're in now, in that the wealth inflating these bubbles is being pumped in by people who are already rich.The distinction O'Reilly makes between the "operating economy" and the "betting economy" is a great one. Our goal should be to stifle the latter virtually out of existence. The vast majority of economic activity and growth should be in the operating economy.
  • culebron21
    I haven't finished reading, but O'Reilly is probably the best man to tell about this.
  • moof11
    Silicon Valley should be nuked. Vaporizing those freaks could save this country!
  • aorloff
    > As Herbert Simon noted in 1971, an abundance of information leads to a scarcity of attention.We are now about 15 years past when most Americans could be expected to have a smartphone, and nearly every kind of long form content is having a little trouble breathing like dinosaurs after a giant meteor. The entire movie industry appears broken and is basically taking its content from youtubers (a refreshing update to a long suffering dinosaur), only a very few (ie: none) musicians can make a living from selling records, and with the exception of perhaps you folks on hacker news, few people read books.
  • sno6
    The irony is not lost on me that this post makes a good 'how to raise capital in 2026' guide.
  • ks2048
    Traditional greed and corruption covers a lot, but it seems the new generation has something even more sinister - “we need all the money and power or else baddies (Chinese, robots, etc) will take over.”
  • blfr
    So are AI companies unprofitable money furnaces with no moat or are they extracting robber baron rents? They surely cannot be both.
  • mrworld
    Greed happened. When both the investors and the founders are focused on short term money over product, it becomes like inbreeding. People and products get less inventive, the pool gets less diverse, everything stalls out until it’s a shit soup. They optimise for an algorithm of rapid acquisition, only slightly different from big players but close enough to catch their eye. Look at me! I’m exactly like you but slightly better!
  • cheesecompiler
    Curious how people here might justify the current reality.
  • mistrial9
    after well-earned fortunes in Book Publishing headed his way in the 1990s, Tim O’Reilly was regularly mocked by serious people behind closed doors for his messianic ego and bold takes from the armchair. Yet some of those serious people included those that built and executed a modern surveillance state.My personal opinion is that this self-important fool has a podium at a critical time and is worth listening to, but judge for yourself
  • RomanPushkin
    Locals failed it. They always vote against building nice high-rise affordable housing. Tech bros drive insane money to SV. They also suffer paying insane rents to local landlords who exploit the local laws. All others suffer because landlords don't want to go to work every day like everyone else. If we build 500 high-rise buildings, we'll have happy kids, families, infrastructure, low rents, artists back in SF.
  • HeavyStorm
    Money happened.
  • profsummergig
    SV has done enough for the world. It's time for payday.
  • tsunamifury
    Let the market be free is what the guy with his hand on the Ouija board says to trick you into believing his movements are just mysterious outcomes.
  • newobj
    the meta became exits instead of out-nerding each other
  • GlacierFox
    It went from an all-round aspirational place to work to something you'd rather keep to yourself depending on the audience. Sort of like if you work for Raytheon.
  • api
    Value extraction is easier if you can do it.I think you can make a base thermodynamic argument. Value creation means climbing hard up against entropy. It means searching large solution spaces. It means risk with unknown payoff.A rough analogy would be drilling a gas or oil well versus replicating what plants do with solar panels or harnessing atomic energy directly. Those are way harder than burning what was already deposited at high concentration. An imperfect but not totally wrong comparison I think.Value extraction just requires that you identify value already there and make a plan to get and store or monetize it.A lot of the debate over the merit of capitalism would be clearer if we made a hard distinction between value creating capitalism and value extracting capitalism. The latter is closer to imperial conquest or raiding the next village but with many more steps and in the modern world often without direct force.The most common way to sack the populace today is trickery and exploitation of the human dopamine system. Financial con games rank highly too.Value creating capitalism gave us modernity and a higher standard of living than Pharaohs. Raiding and conquest was what humans were jacking off doing for all the preceding 100k+ years when standard of living barely moved for most people.
  • leoc
    The statements about shareholder capitalism are a bit strange as an explanation of what happened to Google. As O'Reilly surely knows, thanks to Google's, then Alphabet's, dual-class ownership structure Page and Brin have a majority of the voting rights over Alphabet. Furthermore Google's original IPO prospectus https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1288776/000119312504... seems to have given its shareholders a pretty clear warning of what to expect:> Google is not a conventional company. Eric, Sergey and I intend to operate Google differently, applying the values it has developed as a private company to its future as a public company. Our mission and business description are available in the rest of the prospectus; we encourage you to carefully read this information. We will optimize for the long term rather than trying to produce smooth earnings for each quarter. We will support selected high-risk, high-reward projects and manage our portfolio of projects. We will run the company collaboratively with Eric, our CEO, as a team of three. We are conscious of our duty as fiduciaries for our shareholders, and we will fulfill those responsibilities. We will continue to attract creative, committed new employees, and we will welcome support from new shareholders. We will live up to our “don’t be evil” principle by keeping user trust and not accepting payment for search results. We have a dual-class structure that is biased toward stability and independence and that requires investors to bet on the team, especially Sergey and me.IANAL, but between this and that it seems fairly unlikely that the threat of shareholder lawsuits forced Page and Brin's hand into making Google's behaviour more extractive, and quite certain that the threat of being outvoted didn't. In that case, it seems the problem (at least before the arrival of ChatGPT, after which LLMs really did present a serious threat to Google's business) wasn't the logic of capitalism but one of personal moral decline on the part of Page and Brin. That in turn probably has at least some connection with the recent trend of SV bigwigs turning into frothing far-right lunatics, which also doesn't seem to have been fully justified by the pursuit of shareholder value.In fact the trend now is for people who are sick of tech CEOs playing at overlord to call for the end of dual-class shareholdings. Unfortunately it's not clear how great an answer that is either. For one thing, while dual-class structure obviously didn't stop the rot at Google indefinitely, it's far from clear that things would have gone better, rather than worse, if Google's/Alphabet's leadership have been under the cosh of shareholders eyeing quarterly results. Relying on Page and Brin's good intentions may in fact have been the less-bad option for society at large. Another is that a number of the seemingly-untouchable titans don't in fact have formal majority control, at least not over all of their companies. Musk doesn't seem to have anything like majority voting control over Tesla, for instance.
  • mistic92
    Money happened
  • mindwok
    Brilliantly written article and the best articulation of what's wrong and what we can do about it.There's too much discourse on billionaires and greed, and not enough about the rules of the game. We can't make Elon Musk a better person. We can change the rules of the game, and we should push our ourselves and our governments to do so.
  • musicale
    > We got there the slow way, through steady organic growth. That is quite anathema to the rush to the top of whatever appears to be the latest hill that seems to characterize Silicon Valley today"Today" being the last 35 years at least...
  • musicale
    > [Musk] was getting this incredible lift from the fact that people were giving him credit for 600 years of future profitsP/E ratio of 600 seems crazy unless the assets balance it out somehow.
  • nakedrobot2
    I highly recommend the book "Incorruptible" by Eric Ries. It is about how to build companies that don't become enshittified (financially, or product-wise) and it comes to a similar conclusion: the mission needs to be about "human flourishing". A great book.
  • pjmlp
    Late stage capitalism, is what happened.
  • thom
    I know how tedious it sounds when someone says Marx was right, but idealistic Silicon Valley 'hackers' were always just a reserve army of labour for the capital class.
  • anon
    undefined
  • riazrizvi
    It's helpful to highlight issues. But I'd say the best focus is achieved by pointing the blame at the consumer who has allowed themself to be gamed out of their intentional capacity by other ppl's random agendas. If we don't design the environment we want to live in using our assets we end up with a random environment.Sure there are secondary forces, intentionally predatory, analyzing our behavior and playing us, but the amount of control we exercise in our own proximity is insurmountable in a free society.
  • sl0wbrainRot
    [flagged]